Faherty
12 honest picks, running $48–$228 at the staple level, plus 1,715 browsable catalog products, with owner-sourced reads on how each line holds up. No sponsored picks.
Our Faherty picks
One representative staple per category — the piece we'd actually point a friend at.
How Faherty's lines hold up
Faherty t-shirts — what owners report
Owners mostly praise the fabric on Faherty's organic-cotton tees as soft with good drape, and independent reviewers describe the cut as relaxed without being oversized. The recurring practical complaint is that the material can stretch out over a day of wear and needs a tumble dry rather than air drying to recover its shape. A minority of owners also find the slubby texture rough and question paying around sixty dollars for a basic tee.
- Strengths
- Reviewers consistently single out the soft, draping organic-cotton fabric and a relaxed, true-to-size cut that works on most body types.
- Watch out for
- Fabric that stretches out through the day (needing a tumble dry to snap back) and price-for-value complaints on a roughly sixty-dollar basic are the most repeated criticisms.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report the tees run true to size with a slightly relaxed, boxy-but-not-oversized silhouette.
About Faherty's t-shirts line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? (Style & Serum) · Faherty Women's Sunwashed Short Sleeve Crew T-Shirt — customer reviews (Dick's Sporting Goods) · Faherty Men's Sunwashed Short Sleeve T-Shirt — customer reviews (Dick's Sporting Goods) · Faherty Clothing Review (Honest Brand Reviews)
Faherty hoodies — what owners report
Faherty's hoodie range centers on its stretch-knit Legend fabric, and owner feedback is dominated by softness: reviews of the Legend Sweater Hoodie run near-perfect, with owners saying they could wear it daily and asking the brand for more colors. The recurring gripe is fit rather than quality — several owners found the cut larger and boxier than expected at their usual size, with at least one having it altered. Reviewers also flag the price as high for a hoodie.
- Strengths
- Owners consistently report exceptional softness and stretch, describing hoodies comfortable enough for daily wear.
- Watch out for
- Fit is what draws complaints — a share of owners find the cut large and boxy at their normal size and end up tailoring or exchanging — and the price runs high.
- Sizing
- Listed and mostly reported as true to size, but some owners find the cut large and boxy at their usual size, so buyers wanting a trimmer fit have sized down or tailored.
About Faherty's hoodies line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying | Honest Brand Reviews · Faherty Clothing Review: Worth the Premium Price? | DailyInstaLife
Faherty button-ups — what owners report
Owners describe Faherty's button-ups as unusually soft for casual shirts — brushed cottons and linen blends that drape well — with a slightly relaxed cut that most reviewers say runs true to size. Longer-term owners report the fabrics holding up: one reviewer notes a flannel worn over a year with zero pilling. The consistent pushback is price for a casual shirt, and a minority of Trustpilot reviewers report items shrinking after washing according to the care instructions.
- Strengths
- Reviewers repeatedly single out fabric feel — soft brushed cotton and lightweight linen blends that drape better than the price peers they compare against.
- Watch out for
- The main complaints are the high price for casual shirts and scattered customer reports of shrinkage even when care instructions were followed.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report the shirts run fairly true to size with an intentionally slightly relaxed fit, so most advise taking your usual size rather than sizing down.
About Faherty's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? · Faherty Brand Review - an indigo day · Faherty Clothing Review - Honest Brand Reviews · Faherty Brand Reviews | Trustpilot
Our Faherty button-ups pick: Stretch Movement / Knit Shirt →
Faherty sweaters — what owners report
Reviewers single out Faherty's sweater-knit fabrics for softness — one calls the brand's signature knit "probably the softest thing I own" — and report that pieces hold up with wear rather than degrading. Fit feedback is mixed: coverage describes a true-to-size, slightly relaxed cut, but at least one owner found a knit large and boxy for a normal medium and had it tailored. Price is the most consistent objection, with reviewers calling it high and noting the value case depends on wearing pieces for years.
- Strengths
- Notably soft sweater-knit fabrics that owners report hold up well to regular wear.
- Watch out for
- High prices and a relaxed cut that some owners find large and boxy are the recurring complaints.
- Sizing
- Reports point to a true-to-size but slightly relaxed cut; some owners find knits large and boxy in their usual size.
About Faherty's sweaters line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying · Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium?
Faherty pants — what owners report
Reviewers who have worn Faherty pants across seasons report that the stretch-blend chinos and five-pocket styles hold their shape rather than bagging out, with fabrics described as soft and lightweight without feeling flimsy. Owners place the range between jeans and dress chinos in formality — casual enough for weekends but presentable at an office. The recurring complaints in third-party coverage are the premium prices and cuts some owners find roomy or boxy enough to need tailoring.
- Strengths
- Stretch fabrics that long-term reviewers say hold their shape and stay comfortable over time.
- Watch out for
- Premium pricing and fits some owners find large or boxy enough to require tailoring, with scattered complaints about price and customer service.
- Sizing
- Reviewers mostly find the line true to size, but reports split between roomy, boxy cuts that needed tailoring and more fitted bottom styles one reviewer sizes up in — check the specific cut.
About Faherty's pants line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Brand Review – The Style Guide · Faherty Brand Review – An Indigo Day · Faherty Clothing Review – Honest Brand Reviews
Faherty polos — what owners report
Third-party coverage of Faherty's polos specifically is thin; most independent reporting covers the brand's knits and shirts as a whole. Editorial reviewers praise the soft washed fabrics and the way they drape, and describe the fit as true to size with a slightly relaxed cut. Customer-review aggregators are more critical: the brand's Trustpilot score sits at 1.9/5 — much of it service and shipping complaints — with several owners reporting garments shrinking a full size even when care instructions were followed.
- Strengths
- Fabric softness and drape are what reviewers consistently single out across the brand's knits.
- Watch out for
- The recurring product complaint is shrinkage after washing — one Trustpilot reviewer said items "shrunk an entire size" despite air drying — along with prices that editorial reviewers concede are a tough sell.
- Sizing
- Editorial reviewers describe the fit as true to size with a slightly relaxed cut through the chest and shoulders, though some customer reviews report inconsistent sizing between garments.
About Faherty's polos line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? | Style & Serum · Faherty brand review — The Style Guide · Faherty Brand Reviews | Trustpilot (1.9/5)
Faherty dresses — what owners report
Faherty's cotton-gauze and linen dresses draw strong comfort reviews — testers describe soft, breezy fabric and roomy-but-not-shapeless cuts, and one reviewer called the brand's linen midi shirt dress among the best-fitting she had tried. The recurring theme is generous sizing: multiple styles are reported to run large or boxy, with owners sizing down or having pieces tailored, though at least one style is noted to run slim in the chest instead.
- Strengths
- Soft, breezy natural-fiber fabrics with relaxed cuts that reviewers find genuinely comfortable and easy to care for.
- Watch out for
- Fit skews loose and varies by style — most dresses run large or boxy enough that owners size down or tailor, while a few cut slim in the chest.
- Sizing
- Expect roomy cuts and size down on most styles if between sizes, but check per-style guidance since some run slim in the chest.
About Faherty's dresses line as a whole. Sources: Faherty clothing review: The Kasey dress — Reviewed · Faherty Clothing Review — Honest Brand Reviews · Faherty Brand Review — an indigo day
Faherty jackets — what owners report
Third-party coverage of Faherty's jackets specifically is thin — most independent reviews center on the brand's shirts and knits, with outerwear mentioned in passing. What exists is positive on materials and comfort: one long-term reviewer expects his Teton Jacket to last generations, and brand-level write-ups say the fabric quality is a real step above typical mall brands. The recurring drawbacks are price — reviewers note outerwear can push past $300 — and relaxed, boxy cuts that at least one owner paid to have tailored.
- Strengths
- Soft, comfortable fabrics and casual designs that long-term owners describe as pieces they expect to keep for years.
- Watch out for
- Price is the most common complaint, and the roomy, boxy fit sends some owners to a tailor.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report true-to-size but relaxed fits; one owner found the fit "a little large and boxy for a normal medium" and had it tailored.
About Faherty's jackets line as a whole. Sources: The Essential Faherty Brand Review | Modern Fellows · Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? | Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review | Honest Brand Reviews
Faherty tops — what owners report
Reviewers consistently single out fabric softness across the tops range: one long-term reviewer calls the Legend sweater knit 'probably the softest thing I own,' and owners report the organic-cotton Sunwashed tees stay soft without shrinking after a year of regular wear. Button-downs get credit for clean stitching, substantial buttons and collars that hold their shape. The recurring gripe is price — Trustpilot reviewers judge the shirts expensive for casual basics — alongside scattered reports of tees stretching out through a day's wear, sheerness in lighter linen styles, and inconsistent sizing between garments.
- Strengths
- Owners consistently praise fabric softness and finishing — knits, tees and button-downs that hold their shape and resist shrinking through repeated washing.
- Watch out for
- Recurring complaints are the price for casual basics, tees that stretch out over a day of wear, sheerness in lighter linen styles, and occasional sizing inconsistency between garments.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report tops run true to size with a slightly relaxed cut — one blogger took her usual size in the relaxed button-down and found it 'perfectly loose but not baggy,' while a tee owner sized down after the fabric relaxed with wear.
About Faherty's tops line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? · I've Finally Found T-Shirts That Will Never, Ever Shrink (The Daily Beast) · Faherty Brand Review - an indigo day · Faherty Women's Sunwashed Short Sleeve Crew T-Shirt | Dick's Sporting Goods (customer reviews)
Faherty sweatshirts — what owners report
Owners and reviewers describe Faherty's sweatshirts and sweater-hoodies as very soft and comfortable, with a stretchy fabric that buyers say they reach for daily. The most-reviewed hooded style earns high marks on comfort and quality, though color options are limited. On fit, most call it true to size while a few note it can run large and boxy.
- Strengths
- Reviewers consistently praise the soft, stretchy, comfortable fabric.
- Watch out for
- A few buyers note the fit can run larger and boxier than expected, and color choices are limited.
- Sizing
- Most report it fits true to size, though one Reddit user found a medium a little large and boxy.
About Faherty's sweatshirts line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying
Browse the full Faherty catalog
Every product, live from their store, with an honest verdict on each.