AllSaints vs Faherty: which jean wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the AllSaints Cigarette Skinny Jean at $138, the Faherty Comfort Stretch Jean at $138. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| AllSaints | Faherty | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $138 | $138 |
| Material | Typically a cotton-dominant blend with elastane for stretch, in a mid-weight denim, with some coated and dark-resin finishes. | Typically a cotton-dominant blend with elastane and sometimes added soft fibers for a plush comfort stretch, in a mid-weight denim. |
| Fit | Offered in cigarette, skinny, slim and tapered cuts. Owners report the fits run slim and close to the body, true to size for a fitted leg. | Offered in slim, straight and relaxed cuts. Owners report comfortable, true-to-size fits with generous stretch and give. |
| Quality | Reviewers describe construction and the dark washes as solid for the price, with fitted styling that suits a fashion-forward wardrobe. | Reviewers describe the softness and washes as standouts, though the comfort-stretch construction is positioned for everyday ease rather than rigid longevity. |
| Best for | Shoppers wanting slim, dark, rock-leaning denim with a contemporary edge. | Shoppers who prioritize softness and comfort in a relaxed, coastal everyday jean. |
| Care | Wash cold inside out and air-dry to protect dark and coated finishes from fading. | Wash cold inside out and tumble dry low to protect the soft stretch fibers and color. |
AllSaints' Cigarette Skinny and Faherty's Comfort Stretch are both $138 cotton-dominant stretch jeans, but they pull in opposite directions. AllSaints runs slim, dark and close to the body; Faherty leans soft and relaxed with generous give.
- The case for AllSaints
- Slim/skinny dark cuts, rock-leaning styling, solid dark washes, contemporary fitted look, true to size
- The case for Faherty
- Plush comfort stretch, soft everyday hand, relaxed/straight options, generous give, standout washes
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
No price gap here at all, so this is purely fit and feel. Buy the AllSaints if you want a fitted, dark, edgier silhouette. Buy the Faherty if softness and a relaxed, easygoing cut matter more than a slim line. Faherty's comfort-stretch build is positioned for everyday ease rather than rigid longevity, so skip it if you want denim that holds up hard over years.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.