Faherty vs Patagonia: which zip-up wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the Faherty Faherty Legend Zip Sweater Hoodie at $158, the Patagonia Better Sweater Fleece Jacket at $159, just $1 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Faherty | Patagonia | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $158 | $159 |
| Material | Proprietary Legend sweater knit or soft fleece, mid-weight with a notably plush, brushed interior. | Recycled polyester sweater-knit fleece, ~14oz, fair-trade sewn. |
| Fit | Relaxed, comfortable cut with an easy body; generally true to size with room to layer. | Regular fit, true to size; reads casual-smart rather than athletic. |
| Quality | Smooth zipper, soft ribbed trims and clean seams; finishing supports the cozy, casual intent. | Built to last and be repaired — durable warm fleece, solid zipper; the knit face pills slightly over years. |
| Best for | Comfort-focused buyers wanting an exceptionally soft, relaxed zip layer for coastal-casual wear. | Casual-smart layering, cold weather, and anyone who values longevity and repairability. |
| Care | Machine wash cold gentle and lay flat or tumble dry low to protect the soft knit surface. | Cold wash and tumble low; Patagonia will repair it rather than have you replace it. |
Faherty's Legend Zip ($158) and Patagonia's Better Sweater ($159) are a dollar apart and both go for a sweater-knit fleece look, but they're built for different timelines. Faherty prioritizes hand-feel: a plush brushed interior, a relaxed easy body, and a soft proprietary knit. Patagonia prioritizes longevity: a ~14oz recycled-poly sweater fleece, fair-trade sewn, with a solid zipper and a repair-and-recycle program behind it.
plush brushed interior, softer hand-feel, relaxed roomy fit, room to layer
~14oz durable fleece, repair-and-recycle program, fair-trade sewn, strong cost-per-wear
Which should you buy?
Effectively the same price, so decide on what matters more to you. Buy the Faherty if softness and a relaxed drape are the point and you want the cozier layer. Buy the Patagonia if you want something you'll keep for years: the ~14oz fleece and the repairability drive the cost-per-wear down, with the trade-off that the knit face pills slightly over time. One wins on first touch, the other wins on the long haul.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.