Old Navy vs Hollister: which t-shirt wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the Old Navy Soft-Washed Crew-Neck Tee at $12, the Hollister Cotton Icon Tee (men's) at $13, just $1 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Old Navy | Hollister | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $12 | $13 |
| Material | Cotton or cotton-blend jersey, ~4.5oz, garment-washed soft. | 100% cotton in a light everyday weight; the heavier, washed versions in the line use a thicker cotton but the base Icon tee is a thin summer-weight shirt. |
| Fit | Regular fit, true to size; the soft fabric relaxes slightly with wear. | Sold in slim and regular cuts, sized for the brand's young, narrow block. Coverage of real-world fit is limited, so trying the brand's size guide before ordering multiples is sensible. |
| Quality | Budget. Soft from new but the colour fades and the collar loosens within a year or two of regular wear. | Basic single-stitch construction at a basic price. Short social reviews praise the soft hand for the money, but there is little long-term owner reporting on shrinkage or collar wear, so expect commodity-tee durability rather than anything more. |
| Best for | Everyday rotation, around-the-house wear, and stocking up cheaply on basics. | Shoppers who want the cheapest respectable logo tee in the mall and plan to buy several on the three-for promotion. |
| Care | Cold wash and low heat; the lightweight fabric fades faster with hot drying. | Machine wash cold with like colors and tumble dry low; as a lightweight pure cotton, it will shrink if run through a hot dryer. |
At $12 versus $13, the price gap between these two is effectively nothing — one dollar separates a garment-washed, ~4.5oz cotton-blend tee with a documented fading and collar-loosening track record from a lightweight pure-cotton shirt whose long-term durability is largely unknown but whose fit is cut for a narrower, younger body. The real differentiator is not price but fit geometry and branding intent.
- The case for Old Navy
- The Old Navy tee has actual long-term owner reporting behind it — reviewers confirm it delivers comfort from day one, and at $12 with a regular, broadly fitting cut, it works as a genuine rotation staple for a wider range of body types.
- The case for Hollister
- The Hollister Icon tee is sold in a slim cut suited to narrower frames and is frequently available in multi-pack promotions that push the per-shirt cost below the Old Navy list price, making it the cheaper option in volume for shoppers it fits well.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Old Navy if the goal is a relaxed, true-to-size tee for everyday or around-the-house wear across a normal adult body — the softness is confirmed, the fit accommodates more people, and the durability ceiling, while low, is at least documented. Buy the Hollister if the wearer is young, slim-framed, and purchasing on a three-for promotion, where the per-unit cost drops meaningfully; outside of that deal structure and that fit profile, the one-dollar premium buys nothing except a small logo. Neither shirt represents a durability investment — both should be treated as commodity tees with a lifespan measured in seasons, not years.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.