Banana Republic vs Old Navy: is the pricier jean worth it?
The Old Navy Wow Loose Wide-Leg Jeans (women's) runs $35; the Banana Republic Slim-Tapered Stretch Jean (men's) is $110 — about 3.1× the price ($75 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Old Navy | Banana Republic | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35 | $110 |
| Material | Mid-weight cotton blend (~10–11oz) with a small percentage of elastane; lighter washes are noticeably thinner. | Cotton/poly/elastane blend, ~11oz, with ~2% elastane. |
| Fit | Wide leg, mid-rise. True to size at the waist for most; the inseam runs long, so shorter wearers frequently hem. Sizing down one is common if you want a slightly cleaner waist. | Slim through the thigh, tapered ankle, mid-rise. True to size at the waist; the waistband loosens slightly over a long day of wear. |
| Quality | Budget construction. The colour fades fast and the lighter washes thin at the inner thigh first; stitching itself holds up reasonably for the price. | Solid mid-tier. Clean construction and durable dark washes; the elastane is the main limit on how long the fit stays sharp. |
| Best for | Trend-led casual outfits, warm-weather rotation, and anyone wanting to try the wide-leg look without a real commitment. | Casual offices, smart-casual occasions, and a dressier slot in a daily rotation. |
| Care | Wash cold inside-out and hang dry — owners report the dryer accelerates the fade and shrinks the already-long inseam unpredictably. | Cold wash inside-out and hang dry — the deep indigo washes lose noticeable depth after a hot dryer cycle. |
These two barely compare, and it's worth saying plainly: Old Navy's $35 Wow Loose Wide-Leg is a women's trend-led wide-leg jean, Banana Republic's $110 Slim-Tapered Stretch is a men's office-leaning slim jean, and no shopper is genuinely choosing between them for one body and one job. What the search really asks is how these sibling brands' denim compares, and the answer is disposability-priced trend versus mid-tier longevity.
- The case for Old Navy
- The Old Navy wins on risk-free trend access — an on-trend wide-leg silhouette that mimics pairs costing five to six times more at $35, with reviewers knowingly treating it as a one-season buy and still feeling they got their money's worth.
- The case for Banana Republic
- The Banana Republic wins on build and setting — solid mid-tier construction, durable dark washes, and a slim-tapered cut that works in casual offices, bought with the expectation of more than one season's service.
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
Don't treat this as one decision — it's a women's trend jean versus a men's office jean, different wearers and different jobs. As a read on the brands: buy Old Navy when you want to test a silhouette cheaply and can accept fast fading and thinning lighter washes as the cost of a $35 experiment. Buy Banana Republic when the jean is a working part of a smart-casual rotation and needs to last, accepting that its 2% elastane — not its construction — is what eventually ages the fit. Never pay BR money for a trend you might drop in a season, and never expect Old Navy money to buy multi-year denim.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.