Gap vs Old Navy: is the pricier jean worth it?
The Old Navy Wow Loose Wide-Leg Jeans (women's) runs $35; the Gap '90s Loose Jeans (men's) is $90 — about 2.6× the price ($55 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Old Navy | Gap | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35 | $90 |
| Material | Mid-weight cotton blend (~10–11oz) with a small percentage of elastane; lighter washes are noticeably thinner. | 100% cotton, ~12oz, non-stretch denim. |
| Fit | Wide leg, mid-rise. True to size at the waist for most; the inseam runs long, so shorter wearers frequently hem. Sizing down one is common if you want a slightly cleaner waist. | Loose through thigh and calf, mid-rise. Reads genuinely roomy after years of slim fits. True to size at the waist. |
| Quality | Budget construction. The colour fades fast and the lighter washes thin at the inner thigh first; stitching itself holds up reasonably for the price. | Mid-tier with standout fabric. The 100% cotton is the draw; stitching and hardware are ordinary mall-standard, and the seat is the first wear point. |
| Best for | Trend-led casual outfits, warm-weather rotation, and anyone wanting to try the wide-leg look without a real commitment. | The '90s/2000s roomy silhouette without sourcing vintage, and anyone wanting non-stretch fabric at a mid-tier price. |
| Care | Wash cold inside-out and hang dry — owners report the dryer accelerates the fade and shrinks the already-long inseam unpredictably. | Cold wash inside-out and hang dry to keep the shape — the rigid denim shifts noticeably as it breaks in. |
Old Navy's Wow Loose Wide-Leg is a $35 women's mid-rise wide-leg in ~10–11oz stretch cotton; Gap's '90s Loose is a $90 men's loose fit in rigid ~12oz 100% cotton. These are different pairs for different people — the honest comparison is Old Navy's trend-buy tier against Gap's real-denim tier, and the $55 gap buys non-stretch fabric, not just a label.
- The case for Old Navy
- $35 for an on-trend wide-leg that mimics pairs costing five to six times more; stitching holds up for the price; zero commitment if the silhouette doesn't stick; true to size at the waist
- The case for Gap
- Rigid ~12oz 100% cotton — genuinely uncommon at $90; the roomy '90s silhouette without sourcing vintage; non-stretch denim that breaks in with wear; true to size at the waist
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
First, be clear: one is a women's wide-leg and the other a men's loose fit, so as a head-to-head these barely belong in the same conversation — what searchers are really asking is how the two brands' denim tiers compare. Buy the Old Navy at $35 to test-drive the wide-leg trend; reviewers treat it as a one-season buy and still feel they got their money's worth, but expect fast colour fade, thinning at the inner thigh on light washes, and a long inseam most shorter wearers hem. Step up to the Gap at $90 if you want actual denim — rigid, non-stretch 100% cotton at ~12oz is rare at this price — while knowing the stitching and hardware are ordinary mall-standard and the seat wears first. The $55 buys real fabric; that's the Old Navy vs Gap jeans gap in one sentence.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.