Madewell vs Aritzia: which jean wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean (women's) at $128, the Aritzia Denim Forum High-Rise Jean at $128. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Madewell | Aritzia | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $128 | $128 |
| Material | Cotton/elastane blend, ~12oz; sourced from several mills depending on the run. | Ranges from rigid cotton denim in wide-leg styles to cotton-elastane stretch in fitted cuts, in mid-weight fabrics. |
| Fit | High-rise straight at the natural waist, forgiving through hip and thigh. Sizing varies by wash — check reviews for the specific colour; the elastane relaxes the fit through the day. | Offered across many named fits, including high-rise straight, wide-leg, bootcut and skinny. Owners report fits run true to size with helpful fit guides per style. |
| Quality | Solid mid-tier and the category benchmark. Consistent construction; the elastane is the main limit on long-term shape retention. | Reviewers describe washes and construction as well-developed for the price, with rigid styles holding shape and stretch styles offering good recovery. |
| Best for | A flattering mid-tier high-rise straight for daily rotation that pairs with almost anything. | Trend-aware shoppers wanting a wide range of current rises and leg shapes in quality denim. |
| Care | Cold wash inside-out and air or low-heat dry — high heat noticeably fades the wash and can tighten the fit short-term. | Wash cold inside out and air-dry rigid styles to preserve the fit and wash. |
Madewell's The Perfect Vintage and Aritzia's Denim Forum High-Rise both run $128 in mid-tier denim, so it's a fit-philosophy choice. Madewell is a single benchmark high-rise straight in a 12oz cotton/elastane that relaxes through the day; Aritzia spans many named fits from rigid wide-leg to stretch skinny. One nails a forgiving daily straight, the other offers range.
- The case for Madewell
- category benchmark fit, forgiving hip and thigh, pairs with anything, proven repeat-purchase rate
- The case for Aritzia
- many fits and rises, rigid and stretch options, trend-led leg shapes, helpful per-style fit guides, good stretch recovery
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
At an identical $128, buy The Perfect Vintage if you want one dependable, flattering high-rise straight for daily rotation that owners keep wearing for years. Buy the Denim Forum if you want to shop across rises and leg shapes and care more about current silhouettes than a single safe pair. Madewell's elastane is its one limit on long-term shape; Aritzia's rigid styles hold better if you pick those. Neither is pricier, so choose on whether you want a proven staple or trend range.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.