Re/Done vs MOTHER: is the pricier jean worth it?
The MOTHER The Tomcat (women's) runs $248; the Re/Done 90s High Rise Loose is $295, about 1.2× the price ($47 more). Here is the side-by-side, and what that gap buys.
| MOTHER | Re/Done | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $248 | $295 |
| Material | Cotton/elastane blend, ~11oz; premium mill sourcing. | Often 100 percent cotton rigid denim with authentic vintage-style washes; some stretch options exist but the brand leans rigid. |
| Fit | High-rise, straight with a slight crop and a hand-cut frayed hem. Sizing runs specific — size up one or two from your usual is common advice. | The 90s High Rise is a roomy, vintage-inspired loose cut sitting high on the waist. Reviewers advise checking the size chart, as the rigid fabric offers little give. |
| Quality | Premium construction; the consistency of the cut across drops is the brand's calling card. The frayed hem is intentional, not a flaw. | Owners report sturdy rigid construction and convincing vintage finishing; the rigid denim breaks in over time rather than stretching immediately. |
| Best for | The signature MOTHER aesthetic, premium daily rotation, and anyone who's tried the cut and wants to commit. | Shoppers wanting an authentic vintage-inspired high-rise jean in rigid denim. |
| Care | Cold wash inside-out and air or low-heat dry; the raw hem is meant to fray slightly more with wear. | Wash cold inside out and infrequently to preserve the wash; hang dry to maintain the rigid fabric. |
Re/Done's 90s High Rise Loose ($295) is a roomy, vintage-inspired cut in rigid 100% cotton denim, while MOTHER's The Tomcat ($248) is a high-rise straight with a slight crop and a hand-cut frayed hem in an ~11oz cotton/elastane blend. The Tomcat is $47 cheaper; beyond that, this is silhouette and fabric feel: rigid-and-loose versus stretch-and-straight with a built-in frayed hem.
- The case for MOTHER
- slight crop, hand-cut frayed hem, cotton/elastane stretch, years of proven longevity, consistent cut across drops
- The case for Re/Done
- roomy vintage-inspired loose cut, rigid 100% cotton, convincing vintage finishing, breaks in over time
VerdictWhat the extra money buys
The Tomcat costs $47 less, but silhouette is the main split. Buy the Re/Done if you want a roomy, high-rise loose leg in rigid cotton and don't mind a break-in period with little give. Buy the Tomcat if you want a straight, slightly cropped leg with stretch comfort and a frayed hem, plus owners reporting they wear the same pair for years without the cut going slack. Both run size-specific, so check the chart either way.
This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.

