American Eagle vs Old Navy: is the pricier t-shirt worth it?
The Old Navy Soft-Washed Crew-Neck Tee runs $12; the American Eagle Super Soft Icon T-Shirt is $25 — about 2.1× the price ($13 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Old Navy | American Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $12 | $25 |
| Material | Cotton or cotton-blend jersey, ~4.5oz, garment-washed soft. | Cotton or cotton-blend jersey, ~4.5oz, brushed for softness. |
| Fit | Regular fit, true to size; the soft fabric relaxes slightly with wear. | Slim to classic icon fits; runs slightly slim, size up for a relaxed look. |
| Quality | Budget. Soft from new but the colour fades and the collar loosens within a year or two of regular wear. | Mid — very soft new, but the light blend can pill and bright colours fade with wear. |
| Best for | Everyday rotation, around-the-house wear, and stocking up cheaply on basics. | Soft casual everyday wear, a young laid-back wardrobe, and comfort-first basics on sale. |
| Care | Cold wash and low heat; the lightweight fabric fades faster with hot drying. | Cold wash inside-out and tumble low to limit pilling and fading. |
Two soft budget jersey tees at the same ~4.5oz weight, separated by $13. Old Navy garment-washes for softness at $12; American Eagle brushes for softness at $25. Neither is built to last — the facts on both say the colour fades with regular wear.
- The case for Old Navy
- The Soft-Washed tee costs less than half as much for the same ~4.5oz weight class, fits true to size, and is the obvious buy-in-multiples basic.
- The case for American Eagle
- The Super Soft Icon offers slim and classic cuts where Old Navy only does regular, with a brushed hand that is the softness leader here — and AE's frequent sales close most of the price gap.
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
Buy the Old Navy at $12: same fabric weight, same fade-prone lifespan, half the price. Step up to the AE only if you want the slimmer icon fit or catch one of AE's frequent sales — reviewers rarely pay its full price anyway. At list, the extra $13 buys softness and a trimmer cut, not durability: Old Navy's collar loosens, AE's blend pills, and both fade on a similar clock.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.