MOTHER vs Citizens of Humanity: which jean wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the MOTHER The Tomcat (women's) at $248, the Citizens of Humanity Charlotte High-Rise Straight (women's) at $248. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| MOTHER | Citizens of Humanity | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $248 | $248 |
| Material | Cotton/elastane blend, ~11oz; premium mill sourcing. | 100% cotton, ~12oz non-stretch denim from premium mills. |
| Fit | High-rise, straight with a slight crop and a hand-cut frayed hem. Sizing runs specific — size up one or two from your usual is common advice. | High-rise straight at the natural waist. Runs slightly small at the waist — wearers between sizes size up; rigid cotton with no give, so buy your real waist. |
| Quality | Premium construction; the consistency of the cut across drops is the brand's calling card. The frayed hem is intentional, not a flaw. | Premium construction — stitching, hardware and heavy cloth all above the price; holds shape across years. |
| Best for | The signature MOTHER aesthetic, premium daily rotation, and anyone who's tried the cut and wants to commit. | Premium non-stretch high-rise denim, considered styling, and structured jeans built to last. |
| Care | Cold wash inside-out and air or low-heat dry; the raw hem is meant to fray slightly more with wear. | Cold wash inside-out and infrequently; air dry. The indigo deepens with infrequent washing. |
Both land at $248: MOTHER's The Tomcat is a high-rise straight with a slight crop and frayed hem in an ~11oz cotton/elastane blend, while Citizens of Humanity's Charlotte is a high-rise straight in 100% cotton, ~12oz non-stretch denim. Same price, so the real split is stretch and a styled hem versus heavier rigid cloth and a clean leg.
cotton/elastane stretch comfort, slight crop, hand-cut frayed hem, proven multi-year longevity
heavier ~12oz non-stretch denim, 100% cotton, clean straight leg, holds shape across years, stitching and hardware above price
Which should you buy?
There's no money to save here, so pick on fabric. Go MOTHER if you want a little give, a cropped length, and the frayed-hem look. Go Charlotte if you want heavier rigid cotton with no stretch, a clean hem, and cloth reviewers say clearly out-punches mid-tier denim in the hand. Both run slightly small at the waist, so buy your true waist.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.