We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Faherty tops →NY Knicks Sunwashed Organic Muscle Tank - Light Grey Heather
The verdict
Fit
Muscle tanks are sleeveless and fitted; sunwashed fabrics feel soft and broken-in. Expect close, athletic fit.
Quality
Organic cotton is a step above conventional at this price. Sunwashing softens the fabric; durability is good if cared for.
Is the price fair?
Price is inflated by the licensed logo. The garment itself is solid mid-premium; the label drives the cost.
Best for
Sports fans who want to wear their team; organic cotton appeal is secondary to the Knicks branding.
Care
Wash inside-out in cold water to preserve sunwash finish and logo print; lay flat to dry.
What owners report about Faherty tops
Reviewers consistently single out fabric softness across the tops range: one long-term reviewer calls the Legend sweater knit 'probably the softest thing I own,' and owners report the organic-cotton Sunwashed tees stay soft without shrinking after a year of regular wear. Button-downs get credit for clean stitching, substantial buttons and collars that hold their shape. The recurring gripe is price — Trustpilot reviewers judge the shirts expensive for casual basics — alongside scattered reports of tees stretching out through a day's wear, sheerness in lighter linen styles, and inconsistent sizing between garments.
- Strengths
- Owners consistently praise fabric softness and finishing — knits, tees and button-downs that hold their shape and resist shrinking through repeated washing.
- Watch out for
- Recurring complaints are the price for casual basics, tees that stretch out over a day of wear, sheerness in lighter linen styles, and occasional sizing inconsistency between garments.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report tops run true to size with a slightly relaxed cut — one blogger took her usual size in the relaxed button-down and found it 'perfectly loose but not baggy,' while a tee owner sized down after the fabric relaxed with wear.
About Faherty's tops line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? · I've Finally Found T-Shirts That Will Never, Ever Shrink (The Daily Beast) · Faherty Brand Review - an indigo day · Faherty Women's Sunwashed Short Sleeve Crew T-Shirt | Dick's Sporting Goods (customer reviews)