This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.

Legend™ Sweater Classic Popover - Brown Oat Buffalo

Button-Ups

$94as of Sep 3, 2026. Check the current price at Fahertymay be out of stock

The verdict

Plaid popover at $94 sits mid-range for Faherty women's; solid versatile piece, though construction is standard for the brand.

Fit

Legend line branding suggests a more iconic, longer-lasting silhouette. Popover cut reads relaxed; plaid adds visual structure despite the loose fit.

Quality

Legend branding signals Faherty's confidence in durability. Plaid patterns mask wear; expect reasonable longevity for casual wear.

Price check

Fair mid-range pricing. At $94, it's a practical bridge between entry and premium—plaid adds versatility that helps justify the cost.

Best for

Women wanting a patterned, layerable piece that works across seasons and reads authentically casual.

Care

Wash in cool water to preserve plaid color definition; the mixed fibers (suggested by 'buffalo' in the name) may require gentler handling.

plaidpopoverwomensmid-tierclassic

Have this? Leave a review.

Fit check: Faherty

True to size

Faherty fits true to size with a deliberately relaxed cut — take your usual size, and only size down on the roomiest dresses and boxy tees if you're between sizes.

Owners and hands-on reviewers consistently report Faherty running true to size, with the slight ease built into the cut rather than a sign to size down. The relaxed silhouette shows up across lines — tees are described as boxy-but-not-oversized, pants run about a half-inch generous in the waist (not enough to change size), and some dresses and boxier tops read roomy enough that between-sizes buyers go down. A minority of owners find pieces large and boxy at their usual size — one Reddit user had a medium tailored — and a few customer reviews flag garment-to-garment inconsistency, but that's the exception in the feedback, not the pattern.

Sizing advice: Order your usual size across the line; if you're between sizes, size down only on roomy dresses and boxy tees — everywhere else stay true, since the relaxed drape is intentional.

Per owner & reviewer reports: Faherty Brand Review — An Indigo Day · Faherty Clothing Review — Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review — Honest Brand Reviews

What owners report about Faherty button-ups

Owners describe Faherty's button-ups as unusually soft for casual shirts — brushed cottons and linen blends that drape well — with a slightly relaxed cut that most reviewers say runs true to size. Longer-term owners report the fabrics holding up: one reviewer notes a flannel worn over a year with zero pilling. The consistent pushback is price for a casual shirt, and a minority of Trustpilot reviewers report items shrinking after washing according to the care instructions.

Strengths: Reviewers repeatedly single out fabric feel — soft brushed cotton and lightweight linen blends that drape better than the price peers they compare against.
Watch out for: The main complaints are the high price for casual shirts and scattered customer reports of shrinkage even when care instructions were followed.
Sizing: Reviewers report the shirts run fairly true to size with an intentionally slightly relaxed fit, so most advise taking your usual size rather than sizing down.

About Faherty's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? · Faherty Brand Review - an indigo day · Faherty Clothing Review - Honest Brand Reviews · Faherty Brand Reviews | Trustpilot