We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Indigo Overshirt - Indigo Island Buffalo

Button-Ups

$109as of Sep 3, 2026. Check the current price at Faherty

The verdict

Premium indigo overshirt with organic cotton from India; at 199 USD, it's a style investment justified by the specialized indigo dyeing and weighting.

Fit

Overshirt cut implies a substantial layer piece, likely with a full front button and enough ease to wear over t-shirts. Indigo dyed fabrics have inherent texture; expect a soft, broken-in hand even when new.

Quality

India-made organic cotton indigo with buffalo-style dyeing suggests higher-end Faherty construction. Indigo fades uniquely with wear, developing character; seams and finishing should be refined at this price tier.

Price check

At 199 USD, you're paying premium pricing for specialized indigo dyeing and organic fiber. The price is steep but defensible for a heritage-style overshirt with intentional texture.

Best for

Men investing in a statement-layer piece with character; indigo develops patina and suits a style-conscious wardrobe.

Care

Indigo indigo bleeds in early washes—use cold water, wash inside-out, and avoid mixing with light colors for several washes.

indigo-dyeovershirtorganic-cottonheritage-stylepremium

Have this? Leave a review.

Fit check: Faherty

True to size

Faherty fits true to size with a deliberately relaxed cut — take your usual size, and only size down on the roomiest dresses and boxy tees if you're between sizes.

Owners and hands-on reviewers consistently report Faherty running true to size, with the slight ease built into the cut rather than a sign to size down. The relaxed silhouette shows up across lines — tees are described as boxy-but-not-oversized, pants run about a half-inch generous in the waist (not enough to change size), and some dresses and boxier tops read roomy enough that between-sizes buyers go down. A minority of owners find pieces large and boxy at their usual size — one Reddit user had a medium tailored — and a few customer reviews flag garment-to-garment inconsistency, but that's the exception in the feedback, not the pattern.

Sizing advice: Order your usual size across the line; if you're between sizes, size down only on roomy dresses and boxy tees — everywhere else stay true, since the relaxed drape is intentional.

Per owner & reviewer reports: Faherty Brand Review — An Indigo Day · Faherty Clothing Review — Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review — Honest Brand Reviews

What owners report about Faherty button-ups

Owners describe Faherty's button-ups as unusually soft for casual shirts — brushed cottons and linen blends that drape well — with a slightly relaxed cut that most reviewers say runs true to size. Longer-term owners report the fabrics holding up: one reviewer notes a flannel worn over a year with zero pilling. The consistent pushback is price for a casual shirt, and a minority of Trustpilot reviewers report items shrinking after washing according to the care instructions.

Strengths: Reviewers repeatedly single out fabric feel — soft brushed cotton and lightweight linen blends that drape better than the price peers they compare against.
Watch out for: The main complaints are the high price for casual shirts and scattered customer reports of shrinkage even when care instructions were followed.
Sizing: Reviewers report the shirts run fairly true to size with an intentionally slightly relaxed fit, so most advise taking your usual size rather than sizing down.

About Faherty's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? · Faherty Brand Review - an indigo day · Faherty Clothing Review - Honest Brand Reviews · Faherty Brand Reviews | Trustpilot