We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Faherty jackets & outerwear →Commander Shirt Jacket - Washed Charcoal
The verdict
Fit
Washed charcoal suggests a soft, broken-in feel from the start. Shirt jackets fit open and generous — expect comfortable, unstructured drape.
Quality
At 119 dollars, this is solid casual construction. Cotton shirt jackets age well with repeated washing. Expect 2–3 years of regular wear.
Is the price fair?
Fair mid-market pricing. Not premium, but honest quality for the casual category.
Best for
Reliable everyday layering for anyone wanting a neutral, comfortable shirt jacket without frills.
Care
Warm or cool wash depending on color stability; hang or lay flat to preserve the soft hand.
What owners report about Faherty jackets & outerwear
Third-party coverage of Faherty's jackets specifically is thin — most independent reviews center on the brand's shirts and knits, with outerwear mentioned in passing. What exists is positive on materials and comfort: one long-term reviewer expects his Teton Jacket to last generations, and brand-level write-ups say the fabric quality is a real step above typical mall brands. The recurring drawbacks are price — reviewers note outerwear can push past $300 — and relaxed, boxy cuts that at least one owner paid to have tailored.
- Strengths
- Soft, comfortable fabrics and casual designs that long-term owners describe as pieces they expect to keep for years.
- Watch out for
- Price is the most common complaint, and the roomy, boxy fit sends some owners to a tailor.
- Sizing
- Reviewers report true-to-size but relaxed fits; one owner found the fit "a little large and boxy for a normal medium" and had it tailored.
About Faherty's jackets & outerwear line as a whole. Sources: The Essential Faherty Brand Review | Modern Fellows · Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium? | Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review | Honest Brand Reviews