We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Citizens of Humanity jeans →Elijah Straight Archive Denim in Mid Indigo
The verdict
Fit
Straight silhouette in Citizens' archive proportions—roomier than modern slims. Mid-indigo wash reads classic. Size true for the straight cut.
Quality
Citizens' consistent mid-premium construction; reliable seaming and hardware throughout the archive line.
Is the price fair?
At $238, fair for an archive-sourced straight jean from Citizens.
Best for
Men seeking a classic straight men's jean without premium material claims or contemporary details.
Care
Cold machine wash and air dry for longevity.
Fit check: Citizens of Humanity
Runs largeCitizens of Humanity tends to run about half a size large and stretches with wear, so most owners size down for a fitted look.
A stylist's sizing guide reports the brand "generally run[s] about half a size large" and that owners "expect about an inch of stretch in the waistband after a few hours of wear," advising those between sizes to go down one. Hands-on reviewers back this up across cuts: one who ordered her chart size in the Horseshoe jean found it loose and repurchased a size down, and a shorts reviewer says the relaxed styles "run really big" and always sizes down. The caveat owners flag is line-level: relaxed and baggy cuts run largest, while high-rise styles fit closer to true size — and older forum threads on the skinny-era styles were more mixed.
Sizing advice: Size down one if you're between sizes or want a snug fit — especially in relaxed and baggy cuts, which stretch and loosen with wear; stay true to size only if you want the intentionally slouchy look.
Per owner & reviewer reports: Citizens of Humanity Sizing: Does It Run Big? Your Comple… · Citizens of Humanity Horseshoe Jeans Review (Jeans and a … · Citizens of Humanity Corey Relaxed Denim Shorts Review (T…
What owners report about Citizens of Humanity jeans
Owners report soft denim with a vintage feel and construction that holds up across years and repeat purchases; the stretch blends are noted for loosening with wear but recovering their shape after washing. The rigid all-cotton cuts have no give, and several owners who bought their usual size exchanged for one size up. Complaints center on the no-stretch cuts feeling restrictive through a full day, button-fly closures that divide opinion, and favorite styles being altered between seasons.
- Strengths
- Soft, substantial denim whose construction owners report lasting through years of wear and many washes.
- Watch out for
- The rigid all-cotton cuts have no stretch and run small, and owners complain when the brand changes closures or details on long-running styles.
- Sizing
- Several popular cuts run small — especially through the hips and thighs — so sizing up one size is commonly advised on the rigid styles, while the stretch styles fit closer to true size.
About Citizens of Humanity's jeans line as a whole. Sources: Citizens of Humanity Jeans Review - Must Read This Before Buying · Citizens of Humanity Denim Review: Charlotte and Jolene - Karin Emily · Citizens of Humanity Charlotte Jeans Review - Magpie by Jen Shoop
