Reformation

Reviewers who tested multiple pairs report the draw is the cuts — high rises that actually sit at the natural waist — and soft, comfortable denim; one tester's cotton-blend pair was still holding its shape after nearly two months of regular wear, having relaxed only slightly. The recurring complaint is fit consistency: the same size can run tight in one style and baggy in another, and rigid non-stretch pairs start snug before giving back roughly half a size as the cotton relaxes. A few reviewers also found the denim thinner than they expected at this price.

Strengths

high-rise cuts that sit at the natural waist, with soft denim that held its shape over weeks of wear

Watch out for

fit varies noticeably from style to style; some find the denim on the thin side for the price

Sizing

runs slightly small — size up in rigid 100% cotton styles, order true to size in stretch fabrics

About Reformation's jeans line as a whole. Sources: Reformation Jeans Review: Here's the 411 on Fit & Feel · The Guide To Reformation Jeans: Fit, Styles, & Reviews · Reformation Abby jeans review: Are celeb-loved jeans worth the price?

Our Reformation jeans pick: Cynthia High-Rise Straight (women's)

Reviewers consistently report that the dresses are flattering and comfortable once the size is right, and testers rate the natural-fibre versions — cotton, linen and silk — above the synthetics. Fabric is the main split: one reviewer reports that the viscose and rayon styles fray and create loose fluffs and generally do not hold up over time, which is the most frequently repeated durability complaint. Sizing reports contradict each other, with one tester calling the range true to size across the board and another finding it runs slightly small through the bust and ribcage. Aggregate customer reviews are considerably harsher than the blogger try-ons, with size discrepancy and friction around returns and customer service the most cited problems.

Strengths

Reviewers repeatedly report the cut is flattering and genuinely comfortable in the correct size, and the cotton, linen and silk fabrics draw better durability feedback than the synthetics.

Watch out for

Viscose and rayon styles are reported to fray and fuzz with wear, and aggregate customer reviews flag size discrepancy and returns friction far more often than the try-on blogs do.

Sizing

Sizing reports conflict — some testers call it true to size across the board while others find it tight through the bust and ribcage — and size discrepancy is the single most common complaint in aggregate reviews.

About Reformation's dresses line as a whole. Sources: Reformation Dress Review: How Do Their Clothes Fit? · Reformation Dress Size Review - an indigo day · My Ultimate Guide to Reformation Dresses—Tested & Reviewed, with Photos · Reformation Review - Must Read This Before Buying

Our Reformation dresses pick: Juliette Dress