Reformation vs Carhartt WIP: which button-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Reformation Reformation Will Oversized Shirt at $98, the Carhartt WIP Carhartt WIP Madison Shirt at $98. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Reformation | Carhartt WIP | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98 | $98 |
| Material | Cotton poplin, breathable linen, and fluid TENCEL or silk-blend fabrics chosen for drape and a soft hand. | Cotton oxford and poplin, sturdy twill, and brushed flannel chosen for durability and a clean, casual hand. |
| Fit | Relaxed and oversized with dropped shoulders and a longer hem; meant to be worn loose, tucked, or knotted. | Regular-to-relaxed fit with a clean shoulder and easy body; cut to layer over a tee with a slightly boxy line. |
| Quality | Clean finishing and considered details, though the delicate linens and silk blends require gentler handling and wrinkle easily by nature. | Solid seams, sturdy buttons, and durable cottons reflect the workwear lineage with a tidier streetwear finish. Built for regular wear. |
| Best for | Easy, feminine layering and warm-weather dressing, worn open over a tank or tucked into trousers and skirts. | Workwear-streetwear and clean-casual looks, worn open or layered over a tee with denim and chinos. |
| Care | Follow garment labels closely; many styles are best hand washed or dry cleaned, and linen is meant to be worn relaxed and lightly creased. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; the twill and flannel soften with washing while keeping structure. |
Reformation's Will Oversized is a relaxed, draped shirt in poplin, linen, and fluid TENCEL or silk blends leaning feminine and warm-weather; Carhartt WIP's Madison is a regular-to-relaxed workwear-streetwear shirt in oxford, twill, and brushed flannel built for durable everyday wear. Same $98, with the gap really being delicate drape versus sturdy utility.
Fluid soft drape, breathable linen, dropped shoulders longer hem, feminine warm-weather styling, design and sustainability focus
Durable workwear cloth, sturdy seams and buttons, clean boxy layering line, workwear-streetwear styling, built for regular wear
Which should you buy?
Equal price, opposite builds. Choose the Reformation for an airy, oversized layer in lighter fabrics if you accept easy wrinkling and gentler care. Choose the Carhartt WIP for sturdier cottons and a tidier boxy cut that takes everyday abuse and layers cleanly over a tee. Pick on whether you want delicate drape or workwear durability, since neither is trying to be the other.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.