Quince

Coverage splits along Quince's two hoodie families. Reviewers of the cashmere hoodies call them well-made and unusually soft for the money — one describes the Mongolian cashmere pullover hoodie as "incredibly well-made," another says it "easily looks like it cost double the price." The consistent caveat is pilling: a long-term reviewer concluded the cashmere pills faster than costlier cashmere because Quince uses shorter fibers to hold the price down, and recommends combing it every few wears, while a 2024 revision is reported as thicker and less prone to pilling than earlier stock. On the cotton side, a menswear try-on reviewer found the organic heavyweight fleece hoodie genuinely substantial, crediting the fleece backing, though he had to exchange the small for a medium.

Strengths

Softness and perceived value are the recurring wins — reviewers repeatedly say the cashmere reads as far more expensive than it costs, and the cotton fleece is reported as properly thick rather than thin.

Watch out for

Pilling is the standing complaint on the cashmere hoodies, they need regular combing to stay presentable, and at least one reviewer reported small holes appearing in a machine-washed cashmere hoodie.

Sizing

Cashmere hoodies are reported true to size with a loose, slouchy drape; the organic cotton fleece hoodie fits closer, and one reviewer sized up after the small was too tight.

About Quince's hoodies line as a whole. Sources: Quince Cashmere Review: Every Piece I Own, Honestly Ranked · Quince Haul Review: Here's What's Worth Buying (And Not) · Quince Mongolian Cashmere Hoodie Review + 5 Cozy Outfit Ideas · Quince Menswear Review: The Best Apparel Essentials (Regular Guy Try-on)

Our Quince hoodies pick: Organic Cotton Pullover Hoodie