American Giant

Owners consistently describe American Giant tees as noticeably heavier and more substantial than typical basics — heavy to the touch but comfortable to wear — and report them holding up through daily rotation without stretching out. The pushback is almost entirely about price: even owners who keep the shirts in rotation call them solid rather than exceptional for the money, and a minority report wash problems like curled hems and color that doesn't hold.

Strengths

Substantial, opaque fabric and durable construction that owners say survives heavy daily wear.

Watch out for

Owners question the full-retail price for a plain tee, and a few report hems curling and color fading after washing.

Sizing

Reviewers describe a more tailored cut through the shoulders and chest rather than a boxy basic-tee shape.

About American Giant's t-shirts line as a whole. Sources: Life Beyond the Sweatshirt: American Giant T-Shirt Review | Evolved Threads · American Giant Review: Are Premium Basics Worth It? | The Adult Man · American Giant Reviews | Thingtesting

Our American Giant t-shirts pick: Classic Cotton Crew Tee

Owners describe the line as unusually heavy all-cotton fleece with double-lined hoods, reinforced elbows, and thick stitching at stress points; one reviewer reports his holding up well after nearly two years of wear. The recurring trade-offs reported are that the dense cotton is not very breathable, the zip models can feel drafty in cold wind, and the zippers are sturdy but do not glide smoothly. Price is the most repeated complaint, with reviewers noting most shoppers can find a basic hoodie for far less.

Strengths

Reviewers consistently praise the heavy 13-oz-per-square-yard combed ringspun cotton and reinforced construction, reporting it survives years of regular wear.

Watch out for

Reviewers report the thick cotton runs hot and unbreathable, zippered versions let in drafts in windy cold, and the over-$100 pricing draws repeated pushback.

Sizing

One reviewer's medium felt roomy out of the box and shrank to a proper fit after a single wash, so owners suggest keeping your usual size and drying on low; the Classic cut runs slim and long in the torso while the Relaxed cut is substantially fuller.

About American Giant's hoodies line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Hoodie Review: Really the World's Greatest? | Stridewise · American Giant Review (2024): Are Premium Basics Worth It? | The Adult Man

Our American Giant hoodies pick: Classic Full-Weight Pullover Hoodie

Owners describe American Giant's zip-up range as unusually heavy and durable for a cotton hoodie: one reviewer wore his Classic Full Zip for almost two years and called it a fantastic purchase from day one, and reviewers note the thick 13-oz combed ringspun cotton, YKK zippers, reinforced elbow patches, and a double-lined hood. Reviewers judge it rugged and technically sound but flag that the dense cotton is not very breathable and the zippers do not glide particularly well. Price comes up repeatedly as the main hesitation, with owners deciding the durability justifies it.

Strengths

Heavyweight ringspun-cotton construction that owners report holds its shape and keeps performing after years of regular wear and washing.

Watch out for

Reviewers note the dense cotton runs warm and breathes poorly, the zipper track can feel drafty in wind and does not glide smoothly, and full retail is high for a hoodie.

Sizing

The Classic fit is slim and V-shaped while Relaxed runs much roomier (a Relaxed medium has the same chest as a Classic XL), and the all-cotton fabric shrinks in the dryer, so a slightly large fit out of the box settles after the first wash-and-dry cycle.

About American Giant's zip-ups line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Hoodie Review: Really the World's Greatest? | Stridewise · American Giant Review: Are Premium Basics Worth It? | The Adult Man

Our American Giant zip-ups pick: Classic Full-Zip Hoodie

Owner reports are unusually consistent: the all-cotton fleece is heavy and arrives stiff, then softens and gains stretch over the first weeks of wear and washing. Long-term testers report no visible wear, fading, or loose threads even after using the pants for chores like car repair and dog grooming, and reviewers credit the double-needle stitching. The complaints are about fit rather than fabric — pieces ran small against the size chart and the inseam sat short enough that a lot of leg showed when seated.

Strengths

Durability is the consensus strength — long-term testers report no visible wear, fading, or loose threads under rough daily use.

Watch out for

They arrive stiff and need several wears and washes to break in, and reviewers found both the fit and the inseam run small and short against the size chart.

Sizing

Reviewers found the pants ran small against the brand's size chart and short in the inseam, so sizing up is the common advice, especially for length.

About American Giant's sweatpants line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? - Reviewed · American Giant Review (2024): Are Premium Basics Worth It? - The Adult Man · American Giant Sweatpants Review - Refinery29

Our American Giant sweatpants pick: Classic Sweatpant

Third-party wear tests report American Giant's knit tops hold up through repeated wear and washing, with one tester finding no color fading, loose threads, or shrinkage after several washes. An owner of the merino crew sweater reports it is a merino-and-cotton blend that machine-washes on delicate without shrinking, and expects to keep wearing it every winter. Fit is the recurring caveat: the merino crew ran noticeably oversized on one reviewer, while a tester found a women's french terry crew ran small with narrow sleeves and a hem that rode up.

Strengths

Reviewers consistently report the knits survive repeated washing without fading, shrinkage, or loose threads.

Watch out for

Sizing is inconsistent across styles — owners report the merino crew runs oversized while a women's french terry crew ran small with narrow sleeves.

Sizing

Sources report fit varies by style rather than by brand: the merino crew sweater runs oversized while a women's french terry crew ran small, so check each product's own fit notes instead of assuming one size across the line.

About American Giant's sweaters line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? - Reviewed · American Giant Clothing Review - Lakeshore Lady · American Giant Review (2024): Are Premium Basics Worth It? - The Adult Man

Our American Giant sweaters pick: Cotton Crewneck Sweater

The sweatshirt line is the brand's flagship and draws detailed reviews. Reviewers report heavy 13-oz-per-square-yard combed ringspun cotton fleece, reinforced double-needle stitching, elbow patches, double-lined hoods, and metal zippers, sewn in North Carolina. Long-term owners report no fraying, seam failures, or zipper problems after months to years of regular wear. The recurring gripes are practical: the fabric is heavier and less breathable than buyers expect, it shrinks somewhat in the dryer, and the price is well above mass-market hoodies.

Strengths

Owners consistently report the heavyweight construction holds up — no fraying, warped zippers, or seam failures over extended wear.

Watch out for

The most repeated complaints are heat and heft — the thick cotton is not very breathable — plus some dryer shrinkage and a price several times that of a basic mass-market hoodie.

Sizing

The Classic fit is tapered at the waist and long in the body with an athletic cut, and the fleece shrinks a bit in the dryer — reviewers point buyers who want more room to the roomier Relaxed fit rather than relying on the taper relaxing.

About American Giant's sweatshirts line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Hoodie Review: Really the World's Greatest? — Stridewise · American Giant Review: Are Premium Basics Worth It? — The Adult Man · What is the best hoodie? American Giant Classic Full Zip Hoodie — Mike Gorman

Our American Giant sweatshirts pick: American Vintage Crew Sweatshirt

Owners consistently praise the construction — one reviewer calls the seams, fabric, and overall build top notch — and long-term wearers report the stretch styles hold their shape: a three-year owner says her pair shows no stretching, almost no pilling, and no color fade despite regular machine washing. A tester who wore the chinos and sweatpants near-daily for months, including for car repairs and dog grooming, found no signs of wear. The recurring gripe is length: both chinos and sweatpants were reported to run short enough that leg shows when seated, and some women's styles have undersized or protruding pockets.

Strengths

Durable, shape-retaining fabrics and construction that owners report outlasting cheaper stretch pants over years of regular wear and machine washing.

Watch out for

Inseams reported to run short — fine standing but exposing leg when seated — plus small or protruding pockets on some women's styles.

Sizing

Reviewers report lengths run short in both chino and sweatpant styles, and one between-sizes owner recommends taking the smaller size in the straight-leg stretch pant.

About American Giant's pants line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? (Reviewed) · How Well Does It Age: American Giant's No BS Pant Review (The Chore Nerd) · American Giant No-BS Pant Review: Ethical Pants (Ashleigh Becker)

Shorts-specific coverage is thin, but the one menswear review that covers the line calls the work-style shorts about as hard-wearing a pair as you'll find on the market, and positions the sweatshorts as a step up from basic athletic shorts. Brand-level testing backs that up: reviewers who wore the clothes hard for months report no signs of wear, fading, or loose threads. The caveats are consistent too — the mostly-cotton fabrics shrink a few percent in the wash, some pieces run small, and multiple reviewers say prices sit above what they'd normally pay for basics.

Strengths

Durability is the consistent finding — long-term testers report garments holding up to heavy use with no visible wear.

Watch out for

Reviewers flag shrinkage on the all-cotton fabrics, some items running small, and prices they consider slightly high even for US-made garments.

Sizing

Testers report some pieces run small and that the 100% cotton fabrics can shrink 3-5%, so size with shrinkage in mind rather than sizing down.

About American Giant's shorts line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Review: Your Next Stop For Basic Wardrobe Essentials – Effortless Gent · American Giant Review (2024): Are Premium Basics Worth It? – The Adult Man · American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? – Reviewed

American Giant's dresses are cut from the same French terry and knit fabrics as its fleece, and owners report them comfortable, stretchy, and substantial rather than skimpy, with enough shape to avoid looking like a sack. Testers of the broader line found no color fading, loose threads, or shrinkage after wear and washing, and long-term owners say the construction outlasts ordinary sweatshirts. Recurring complaints center on price, sizing that runs small against the charts, and women's pieces that trade function for looks — one tester's front pocket fit only half a phone.

Strengths

Durable, well-made knit fabric that testers report survives heavy wear and washing without fading, loose threads, or shrinkage.

Watch out for

Pieces run small versus the size chart, prices draw complaints, and slow shipping plus inconsistent customer support recur in reviews.

Sizing

Reviewers report American Giant runs small compared to its own size charts, so consider sizing up — though the dress fabrics are stretchy and forgiving.

About American Giant's dresses line as a whole. Sources: American Giant Hoodie Dress Review — The Frugal Girl · American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? — Reviewed · American Giant Review — Honest Brand Reviews

Reviewers consistently report that American Giant's tees are heavier and more substantial than typical department-store cotton while still wearing light, with construction that holds up through repeated wear and washing without fading, loose threads, or long-term issues. The cut is described as tailored through the shoulders and chest without being tight, and the fabric is not see-through even in lighter colors. The recurring criticisms are price — reviewers call it slightly high even for US-made garments and point to frequent sales as the better entry point — and one reviewer flagged a thick decorative back seam on a shirt as uncomfortable when sitting back in a chair.

Strengths

Durable, well-constructed cotton tees that reviewers report surviving daily wear and multiple washes with no fading or loose threads.

Watch out for

Full price draws value complaints even from positive reviewers, and the all-cotton fabric shrinks in the dryer — one reviewer deliberately shrank a tee to size but warned it could just as easily go too far.

Sizing

Order true to size but plan for dryer shrinkage — the brand's own guidance cited by a reviewer says the 100% cotton shouldn't shrink more than 3-5%, and reviewers use a wash-dry cycle to dial in fit.

About American Giant's tops line as a whole. Sources: Life Beyond the Sweatshirt: American Giant T-Shirt Review | Evolved Threads · American Giant Review: Are Premium Basics Worth It? | The Adult Man · American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? - Reviewed

Editorial coverage of American Giant's button-up shirts centers on the flannel and linen models; reviewers report sturdy buttons, durable construction, and fabric that is light enough to breathe but warm enough to layer. A month-long test of the wider range found no fading, loose threads, or shrinkage and concluded the quality warrants the price. Buyer reviews mostly agree on construction, though some report pilling, fading within the first washes, and hardware failures on other garment types.

Strengths

Reviewers consistently report durable, US-made construction with sturdy buttons and stitching that hold up to regular washing.

Watch out for

The most repeated complaint is that pieces run small against the brand's own size charts, with scattered buyer reports of fading and pilling.

Sizing

Testers found items run small compared to the brand's sizing charts, so consider sizing up if between sizes.

About American Giant's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: Style Pick of the Week: American Giant Vintage Flannel Shirt – The Style Guide · American Giant Review: Are the made-in-America clothes worth it? - Reviewed · American Giant Reviews | Read Customer Service Reviews of american-giant.com

Reviewers describe American Giant's jackets and heavier zip-up outerwear as thick, dense, and sturdily constructed, noting the fabric feels substantial and holds its shape. The Mechanic's Jacket is made in the U.S. from canvas with a water-repellent treatment, and reviewers say it feels sturdy without being stiff and is expected to break in and improve with wear. The cut runs long in the body and tapers, which reviewers frame as a more fitted look rather than a boxy one. The main trade-off owners flag is the premium price, though the lifetime warranty is cited as justification for the cost.

Strengths

Reviewers consistently praise the heavy, dense build quality, U.S. construction, and the lifetime warranty backing the pieces.

Watch out for

The recurring complaint is the high price relative to comparable outerwear.

Sizing

Reviewers note the fit runs long in the body and tapers toward the waist, reading as fitted rather than boxy, so those wanting a relaxed drape should check the fit options.

About American Giant's jackets line as a whole. Sources: Layer Up this Fall with American Giant and Your New Favorite Fall Jacket - The Manual · American Giant Review (2024): Are Premium Basics Worth It? · American Giant Hoodie Review: Really the World's Greatest? | Stridewise

Menswear reviewers describe American Giant's polos as casual, tee-like takes on the polo, made in Los Angeles from cotton: one review of the slub version calls the fabric lightweight and breathable without being overly thin, with a body that falls below the belt line without running long. Blog coverage of the polos themselves reports no durability problems and calls the roughly $70 pricing fair for US-made construction. Brand-level customer reviews are less uniform: alongside a 4.4/5 Trustpilot average, recurring complaints cite pilling, fabric fading within a wash or two, and inconsistent quality between batches on other garments in the range.

Strengths

Reviewers rate the polos' US-made cotton construction and casual cut highly, with fabric described as breathable without being thin and length that sits right at the belt line.

Watch out for

Polo-specific complaints are scarce, but brand-level customer reviews repeatedly report pilling, fading after one or two washes, and batch-to-batch quality inconsistency, so quality can vary by production run.

Sizing

Reviewers describe the body length as falling below the belt line without proving overly long; sources report no consensus to size up or down.

About American Giant's polos line as a whole. Sources: The Thursday Buy: USA-Made Polo from American Giant — The Style Guide · American Giant Review — Effortless Gent · American Giant Reviews — Trustpilot