American Giant vs Carhartt WIP: which zip-up wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the American Giant Classic Full-Zip Hoodie at $135, the Carhartt WIP Carhartt WIP Chase Zip Hoodie at $135. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| American Giant | Carhartt WIP | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $135 | $135 |
| Material | Heavyweight cotton fleece, ~13–15oz, made in the USA with reinforced panels. | Heavyweight cotton fleece with a soft brushed interior and a substantial, structured hand. |
| Fit | Athletic substantial fit, true to size; structured and warm, stiff until broken in. | Relaxed streetwear cut with an easy body; check the specific style, as fits vary across the range. |
| Quality | Exceptional — dense reinforced fleece, durable chunky zipper, built to last many years of hard wear. | Sturdy zipper, thick ribbing and neat embroidery; finishing matches the established streetwear standard. |
| Best for | A buy-once heavyweight zip-up, cold weather, and anyone who values longevity over fashion. | Streetwear buyers wanting a clean, heavyweight cotton zip hoodie with subtle Carhartt WIP branding. |
| Care | Cold wash and tumble low; the heavyweight fleece softens slightly with wear and holds shape for years. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; wash inside out to protect the embroidered logo. |
Both are $135 heavyweight cotton zip hoodies, so the choice is build philosophy, not price. American Giant runs a ~13-15oz made-in-USA fleece with reinforced panels and exceptional durability in an athletic, true-to-size cut. Carhartt WIP's Chase is heavyweight cotton too, but in a relaxed streetwear silhouette with subtle branding.
13-15oz made in USA, reinforced panels, exceptional longevity, athletic structured fit
Relaxed streetwear silhouette, soft brushed interior, subtle Carhartt WIP branding, thick ribbing
Which should you buy?
At the same $135, choose the American Giant if you want maximum durability and a structured athletic fit, accepting that it's stiff until broken in. Choose the Carhartt WIP if you want the relaxed streetwear cut and the brand's look with a softer brushed interior. American Giant wins outright on documented longevity and reinforced construction; Carhartt wins on fit and street credibility. Same money, so decide between buy-once toughness and the streetwear silhouette.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.