Everlane vs Madewell: which jean wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Everlane The Way-High Jean (women's) at $98, the Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean (women's) at $128, just $30 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Everlane | Madewell | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98 | $128 |
| Material | ~12oz organic cotton denim, no stretch. | Cotton/elastane blend, ~12oz; sourced from several mills depending on the run. |
| Fit | High-rise (~12 inches), straight leg, slim through the waist, cropped ankle. Runs slightly small at the waist — many size up one. Stiff until broken in. | High-rise straight at the natural waist, forgiving through hip and thigh. Sizing varies by wash — check reviews for the specific colour; the elastane relaxes the fit through the day. |
| Quality | Solid mid-tier. Clean stitching; the rigid organic cotton is the selling point and what gives it the structured drape. | Solid mid-tier and the category benchmark. Consistent construction; the elastane is the main limit on long-term shape retention. |
| Best for | A true high-rise, non-stretch silhouette and structured looks, without paying premium-denim prices. | A flattering mid-tier high-rise straight for daily rotation that pairs with almost anything. |
| Care | Cold wash inside-out and air dry; infrequent washing deepens the indigo over time. | Cold wash inside-out and air or low-heat dry — high heat noticeably fades the wash and can tighten the fit short-term. |
Everlane's Way-High is $98 of rigid ~12oz organic cotton with a true ~12-inch rise and zero stretch; Madewell's Perfect Vintage is $128 of ~12oz cotton/elastane that forgives through the hip and thigh. The cloth weights match — the $30 gap buys stretch comfort and the category-benchmark fit, not heavier denim.
- The case for Everlane
- $30 cheaper; rigid non-stretch structure with the sculpted, structured drape stretch can't give; organic cotton; the non-stretch high-rise category is mostly premium-priced, so this genuinely undercuts the obvious alternatives.
- The case for Madewell
- Comfortable from day one with no break-in; forgiving through hip and thigh; the benchmark high-rise straight that pairs with almost anything; reviewers report years of weekly wear, and the repeat-purchase rate backs the fit.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Everlane at $98 if you want the true rigid high-rise silhouette — size up one at the waist and accept a stiff break-in period, because the structure is the payoff. Buy the Madewell at $128 if you want comfort immediately and a fit that forgives real bodies; just check reviews for your specific wash, since sizing shifts between them. Know the elastane trade too: Madewell's stretch relaxes through the day and limits long-term shape retention, where the Everlane's rigid cotton holds its shape. The extra $30 buys ease, not more denim.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.