Taylor Stitch vs Ted Baker: is the pricier polo worth it?
The Ted Baker Zeiter Slim Fit Pure Cotton Polo runs $69; the Taylor Stitch The Cotton Hemp Polo is $70 — about 1.0× the price ($1 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Ted Baker | Taylor Stitch | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $69 | $70 |
| Material | 100% cotton in a soft-touch interlock knit, giving a smoother, dressier surface than standard pique. | A 4.5-oz. knit of 70% organic cotton and 30% hemp, garment dyed and washed for a soft, pre-faded finish. |
| Fit | Ted Baker's slim fit is effectively extra slim — fitted close to the body all over — and the Zeiter runs small, with retailer guidance to order one size up. A regular-fit version of the Zeiter has also been sold through third-party retailers. | The cut is tailored and trim, in line with reviewer descriptions of the brand's polos as tailored rather than boxy. Anyone wanting a looser drape through the body should consider going up a size. |
| Quality | Finishing is a step above basic polos, with a webbing-trimmed placket, split hem and branded buttons. The smooth interlock is a dressier, lighter-duty knit than a rugged sports pique, so treat it as a smart-casual piece rather than a knockabout one. | Independent reviewers testing the brand's garments report consistent build quality and durability across the line, and the brand blends hemp with cotton partly for strength. Long-term owner reports specific to this polo are still thin. |
| Best for | Slimmer builds who want a close-fitting, polished polo for smart-casual wear rather than an athletic-cut sports pique. | Best for warm-weather casual wear — someone who wants the ease of a tee with a collar rather than a structured pique polo. |
| Care | Machine wash cold (30°C) and dry flat to hold the slim shape; the brand says it may also be dry cleaned. | The brand's care guidance is to wash cold and tumble dry low; the color arrives pre-faded from the garment dye, so it is not meant to look box-fresh. |
At $69 and $70 respectively, these two polos are effectively the same price, so the question is not whether a premium is justified but which garment better fits the buyer's intended use — a dressier, finishing-forward cotton interlock piece versus a relaxed, pre-faded cotton-hemp casual wear item. The Ted Baker leans smart-casual with smoother construction details; the Taylor Stitch leans weekend-casual with a softer, worn-in character. Neither has a meaningful price advantage over the other.
- The case for Ted Baker
- The Ted Baker wins on polish: the interlock knit, webbing-trimmed placket, split hem, and branded buttons deliver a noticeably dressier finish that works in smart-casual settings where a standard pique polo would look too sporty.
- The case for Taylor Stitch
- The Taylor Stitch wins on material character and casual wearability: the 30% hemp content adds durability to the knit, the garment-dye and wash process delivers a soft, pre-faded texture from the start, and the cut is relaxed enough to wear like a step-up tee.
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
Buy the Ted Baker if the goal is a slim, polished polo that reads dressed-up — specifically on a slimmer frame comfortable sizing up one, and only at the discounted $69 price rather than the $120 list price, which is largely brand positioning. Buy the Taylor Stitch if the priority is low-effort warm-weather casual wear with a softer hand and a fabric blend built to last through repeated washing; the organic cotton-hemp construction and garment dye are real material differences, not just marketing. At a $1 gap, the choice is entirely about use case, not value.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.