Ted Baker vs Reformation: which skirt wins?
Both land in the luxury tier — the Ted Baker GUINEVERE Raised Embroidery Cotton Midi Skirt at $200, the Reformation Layla Silk Skirt at $218, just $18 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Ted Baker | Reformation | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $200 | $218 |
| Material | Ted Baker lists the GUINEVERE at 100% cotton with raised floral embroidery on an A-line body; fabrics vary across the skirt line, and the pleated midis are listed at 100% polyester. | Reformation lists the fabric as 100% silk in a 19mm charmeuse; the linen and polyester Layla variants use the same silhouette in different cloth. |
| Fit | A high-waist A-line midi sold in standard US sizes 0-14 rather than the brand's older Ted sizing. Aggregated renter reviews of a Ted Baker skirt skew true to size, with a minority reporting it big in the waist. | It is a bias-cut midi with an elastic waistband designed to be worn high- or low-rise, hitting a few inches above the ankle on most heights. Reformation notes customers find Layla styles run large and recommends sizing down between sizes; one reviewer found the waist too big on her. |
| Quality | Durability reports specific to this style are thin. A verified owner rated the brand's pleated midi five stars, and renters scored a Ted Baker skirt 4.5 out of 5 across 39 reviews, which supports the line's finish without proving long-term wear. | Long-term owner reports are limited but positive — one owner says hers still looked brand new after a year, with no pilling — and no recurring construction complaints surfaced in reviews. |
| Best for | Someone who wants one floral midi that can cover weddings, showers, and dressed-up office days, and accepts a label premium to get embroidered cotton rather than a printed synthetic. | Right for someone who wants one dressier silk midi that covers weddings, events, and office wear, and who will size down and accept dry-clean upkeep. |
| Care | The product page lists fiber content but no wash guidance, so follow the sewn-in label; washing cold inside out and line drying is the safe default for embroidered cotton. | Reformation lists the silk version as dry clean only, so budget for cleaning costs on top of the purchase price. |
The $18 gap between these two skirts is almost negligible, but the materials underneath it are meaningfully different: the Ted Baker is embroidered cotton built for structured occasionwear, while the Reformation is a 19mm silk charmeuse cut on the bias for a fluid, dressier drape. The real cost comparison is not $200 versus $218 but cotton-with-embellishment versus true silk, two different propositions at nearly the same price point.
- The case for Ted Baker
- The GUINEVERE delivers tangible construction detail — raised embroidery, pockets, and a breathable cotton body — that justifies its price more concretely than branding alone, making it the more versatile daytime-to-occasion piece with easier care.
- The case for Reformation
- The Layla's 19mm silk charmeuse is a superior base fabric for a skirt at this price tier, and one owner confirms it held its appearance without pilling after a year of wear, which is a meaningful data point given silk's reputation for delicacy.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Ted Baker if the priority is a structured, embroidered skirt that moves from office to outdoor weddings without dry-cleaning bills, and where pockets and cotton breathability matter — the $200 price is high for cotton but the embroidery and construction are real content. Step up to the Reformation if the goal is a bias-cut silk midi for formal or evening-leaning occasions where drape and fabric quality read clearly on the body, and the owner is prepared for dry-clean upkeep and sizing down. The $18 gap is not the real question; the question is whether silk charmeuse or embroidered cotton fits the actual use case, and on that basis neither price is obviously wrong.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.