Taylor Stitch vs AllSaints: which zip-up wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the Taylor Stitch Après Zip Hoodie at $138, the AllSaints Brace Zip Hoodie at $138. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Taylor Stitch | AllSaints | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $138 | $138 |
| Material | Heavyweight 14-oz. 100% organic cotton French terry with a smooth face, cozy interior and a dense hand that breaks in over time. | Soft cotton fleece, mid-weight with a smooth brushed interior and clean surface. |
| Fit | Classic, slightly relaxed cut with room to layer; generally true to size. | Slim contemporary cut with a clean shoulder; runs trim, so consider sizing up for a relaxed line. |
| Quality | Two-way YKK zipper, heavyweight ribbing at every opening and a lined three-piece hood; built to take wear and develop character. | Quality zipper, neat seams and a structured collar; finishing reflects the contemporary positioning. |
| Best for | Buyers wanting a durable, heavyweight organic-cotton zip hoodie with a rugged everyday character. | Buyers wanting a slim, moody-minimal cotton zip hoodie with a contemporary edge. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; indigo colorways can transfer dye onto light fabrics at first. | Machine wash cold gentle and lay flat or tumble dry low to keep the soft cotton in shape. |
Both hoodies sit at an identical $138 price point, so the choice is entirely about what kind of garment the buyer actually wants rather than whether a premium is justified. The Taylor Stitch is a 14-oz heavyweight organic cotton workhorse built to develop character over years of hard use; the AllSaints is a mid-weight slim-cut piece oriented toward a cleaner contemporary silhouette. There is no markup gap to interrogate — only a lifestyle one.
- The case for Taylor Stitch
- The Taylor Stitch wins on raw material substance: 14-oz organic French terry is meaningfully heavier and more abrasion-resistant than the AllSaints fleece, and the two-way YKK zipper with heavyweight ribbing at every opening signals a construction hierarchy built for longevity over aesthetics.
- The case for AllSaints
- The AllSaints wins on fit and immediate wearability: the slim, structured cut with a clean shoulder line reads more contemporary and polished out of the box, without the break-in period or dye-transfer caution that comes with the Taylor Stitch indigo colorways.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the AllSaints if the priority is a trim, modern silhouette that looks intentional on day one and fits into a cleaner wardrobe aesthetic — the construction is competent and the cut does the work at the same price. Buy the Taylor Stitch if the priority is a hoodie that absorbs daily punishment, adds weight and presence, and improves with age — the 14-oz organic terry and durable hardware represent a genuinely different durability proposition, not a brand premium, at the same dollar figure.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.