Saint Laurent vs Givenchy: which button-up wins?
Both land in the luxury tier — the Saint Laurent Slim Silk / Cotton Shirt at $690, the Givenchy Givenchy Cotton Poplin Shirt at $690. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Saint Laurent | Givenchy | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $690 | $690 |
| Material | Fine cotton, silk or silk blends, fluid hand. | Fine cotton poplin and structured cottons, with some printed or branded styles using treated or logo-detailed cloth. |
| Fit | Very slim lean fit, true to size or size up; cut for a sharp silhouette. | Sharp tailored fit with a clean shoulder and trim body; cut for a polished, contemporary silhouette. |
| Quality | Luxury — good fabric and clean construction; the value is design and brand. | Refined seams, fine buttons, and precise finishing reflect luxury-house standards. Construction is consistent with the designer tier. |
| Best for | Sharp designer statements, slim builds, and rock-influenced fashion dressing. | Polished luxury and evening dressing, from sharp poplin dress shirts to logo-led statement styles. |
| Care | Follow label; silk and fine styles usually require gentle or professional care. | Dry clean or follow garment labels; handle printed and branded styles with care to protect the finish. |
Both Saint Laurent and Givenchy land at $690, so this is a pure aesthetic call, not a price one. Saint Laurent's slim shirt uses fine cotton or silk blends with a fluid hand and a very lean, rock-influenced cut; Givenchy's poplin is structured cotton with a clean shoulder and trim, contemporary tailoring. Same money, two different house signatures.
Fluid silk-blend option, very slim lean fit, rock-influenced statement, sharp slim silhouette
Structured crisp poplin, clean shoulder line, polished contemporary tailoring, logo-led statement styles
Which should you buy?
With identical $690 pricing, choose on silhouette and fabric feel, not cost. Take Saint Laurent if you want the leanest cut and a softer silk-blend drape for a rock-leaning look. Take Givenchy if you prefer crisp poplin structure and a polished, trim-but-not-skintight contemporary line. There's no money to save either way, so buy the house whose styling you'd actually reach for.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.