Re/Done vs Citizens of Humanity: which top wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the Re/Done Ribbed Tank at $95, the Citizens of Humanity Isabel Rib Tank at $98, just $3 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Re/Done | Citizens of Humanity | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $95 | $98 |
| Material | The brand lists it as 100% cotton rib, knitted and sewn in the USA. | Retailer listings give the fabric as 49% cotton (organic, per one listing), 49% lyocell, and 2% spandex in a lightweight ribbed knit, made in the USA. |
| Fit | Scoop neck with slim straps and an intentionally tight, regular-length cut. It runs small, and both the brand and its retailers advise sizing up. | The cut is close to the body with a high neckline, and the brand lists the fit as true to size. Anyone who wants drape rather than hold should look to the looser tanks in the line instead of sizing games. |
| Quality | Construction is simple — a single-fabric cotton rib knitted and sewn in the USA. Owner reports describe fabric that stays comfortable and keeps its snug hold with wear, with slight sheerness as the main trade-off. | A boutique write-up credits reinforced seams and a rib that holds its shape wash after wash; owner ratings at one department store average 4.2 of 5 across 11 reviews — positive, but a small sample. |
| Best for | Right for someone who wants one snug, US-made rib tank for layering and everyday wear and is willing to pay premium-tier money for it. | Right for someone who wants one close-fitting, polished tank to layer under a blazer or wear alone, and who accepts premium-tier pricing for it. |
| Care | Retailer guidance is to wash cold; air-drying is the safer route to keep the tight rib fit predictable. | Machine washable per retailer listings; washing cold and air-drying will help the ribbed knit keep its stretch and shape. |
At $95 and $98 respectively, these two US-made ribbed cotton tanks are separated by $3 — a gap so small it is functionally irrelevant to the buying decision. The real difference is in fabric and fit philosophy: Re/Done is a 100% cotton rib that runs tight and intentionally small, while the Citizens of Humanity Isabel adds lyocell and spandex to a true-to-size close cut, trading some of Re/Done's raw cotton feel for a more stable, shape-retaining knit. Both prices include meaningful brand positioning on top of the underlying construction cost.
- The case for Re/Done
- Re/Done wins on material purity — 100% cotton rib means no synthetic or semi-synthetic content, which suits anyone who wants a straightforward natural-fiber feel against the skin.
- The case for Citizens of Humanity
- Citizens of Humanity wins on dimensional stability — the 49% lyocell and 2% spandex blend, reinforced seams, and true-to-size cut deliver a rib that owners report holds its shape wash after wash without the sizing guesswork Re/Done's intentionally small cut requires.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Re/Done if pure cotton construction and a snug, lived-in fit that softens gradually with wear are the priority, and sizing up one size is not a friction point. Step up to — or rather, step sideways to — the Citizens of Humanity Isabel if a polished, consistent fit straight off the rack matters more, particularly for structured layering under a blazer where a collapsing rib would show; the spandex content and reinforced seams make that use case more reliable. The $3 gap justifies nothing on its own, so the decision turns entirely on cotton-only versus a stabilized blend, not price.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.