Proper Cloth vs AllSaints: which chino to buy, and when
Both land in the premium tier: the Proper Cloth Cotton Stretch Chino at $135, the AllSaints Tallis Cotton Chino at $139, $4 apart. Here is how they stack up, head to head.
| Proper Cloth | AllSaints | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $135 | $139 |
| Material | Cotton stretch twill with elastane for comfort and a smooth, refined hand; a mid-weight fabric chosen for a clean, slightly dressy look. | Cotton twill, often with a touch of stretch, finished smooth and frequently garment-dyed for the brand's washed, muted tones. |
| Fit | Mid rise in slim and tailored cuts, with custom sizing available; cut for a clean, precise leg line that breaks neatly. | Mid rise in slim and tapered cuts with a close, modern leg; cut for a sharp, urban silhouette. |
| Quality | Carefully finished with fit-focused construction and reliable stretch recovery; the considered fabric holds a clean line. An elevated, fit-led make. | Cleanly finished with construction suited to the slim look; the garment dyeing gives a lived-in tonal face. Built for fashion-forward casual wear. |
| Best for | Fit-focused dressers who want a clean, slightly dressy stretch chino with custom sizing options. | Those who want a moody, slim, urban cotton chino in washed muted tones. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and hang or tumble dry low, or press for a crisper line. | Machine wash cold inside out or follow the label; the garment-dyed tones may settle slightly with washing. |
Proper Cloth and AllSaints are $4 apart, both slim and mid-weight, but the money buys different things. Proper Cloth sells fit precision, elastane stretch, and custom sizing; AllSaints sells a moody, garment-dyed urban look in washed muted tones.
- The case for Proper Cloth
- Cheaper by $4, custom sizing available, reliable stretch recovery, fit-led construction, clean dressy line
- The case for AllSaints
- Garment-dyed washed tones, sharp urban silhouette, design-driven styling, close modern leg
VerdictThe pick
The $4 difference is meaningless, so decide on intent. Go Proper Cloth if you care about an exact, dressy fit and want the custom-sizing option to nail the leg line. Go AllSaints Tallis if you want the washed, tonal, fashion-forward face and a close urban cut. Skip the Tallis if you'd trade the moody dye job for fit precision and dependable stretch.
This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.