Old Navy vs American Eagle: which hoodie wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the Old Navy Gender-Neutral Vintage Hoodie at $30, the American Eagle Super Soft Pullover Hoodie at $45, just $15 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Old Navy | American Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $30 | $45 |
| Material | Cotton-blend fleece, ~7oz, garment-washed soft. | Cotton-blend fleece, ~8.5oz, soft brushed interior. |
| Fit | Relaxed everyday fit, true to size; softens further with wear. | Relaxed current fit, true to size; reads casual. |
| Quality | Budget — soft from new but the fleece thins and the colour fades within a year of regular wear. | Budget — soft and on-trend, but the mid-weight fleece pills and fades over a year of wear. |
| Best for | Everyday rotation, around-the-house comfort, and cheap layering basics. | Soft everyday rotation, a current casual look, and value on promo. |
| Care | Cold wash and low heat to slow the fade and keep the soft hand. | Cold wash inside-out and tumble low to keep the soft hand and colour. |
Two soft cotton-blend budget hoodies $15 apart. Old Navy's Vintage runs ~7oz garment-washed fleece at $30; AE's Super Soft steps up to ~8.5oz at $45. Both are honest one-year pieces — the facts on each say the fleece thins or pills and the colour fades with regular wear.
- The case for Old Navy
- At $30, often less on promo, the Vintage hoodie is the cheapest way into a soft, true-to-size relaxed fleece that softens further with wear.
- The case for American Eagle
- The AE Super Soft carries noticeably more fleece (~8.5oz vs ~7oz), a more current relaxed cut, and drops well under $45 on AE's constant sales.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
If this is an around-the-house layer, buy the Old Navy and pocket the $15 — the roughly one-year fade timeline is the same either way. Step up to the AE if you want the heavier ~8.5oz fleece and a cut you would wear out of the house, ideally on sale where the gap shrinks to almost nothing. Paying full list for either is the only real mistake here; both brands run promotions constantly.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.