Lucky Brand vs Abercrombie & Fitch: which button-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Lucky Brand Lucky Brand Western Shirt at $70, the Abercrombie & Fitch Abercrombie Signature Poplin Shirt at $70, just $1 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Lucky Brand | Abercrombie & Fitch | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $70 | $70 |
| Material | Washed cotton, cotton-blend flannel, and lightweight printed cottons; some styles add a small amount of stretch. | Cotton poplin and oxford, linen-cotton blends for warm weather, and brushed flannel; some fitted styles include a touch of stretch. |
| Fit | Classic and slightly tapered fits with a lived-in drape; western styles taper through the waist with longer tails. | Available in slim, classic, and relaxed cuts; the slim runs trim through the body while the relaxed offers a fuller, easygoing drape. |
| Quality | Decent snaps and stitching for the price, though heavy washing means the lighter cottons can show wear sooner. Detailing leans decorative and vintage-inspired. | Tidy construction and consistent collars for the price, with poplin holding a crisper finish than the softer washed styles. Reliable everyday quality. |
| Best for | Vintage-leaning casual outfits and western-inspired looks, worn open over a tee or with denim. | Smart-casual and date-night dressing, plus relaxed weekend layering across seasons. |
| Care | Machine wash cold to preserve the washed finish; tumble dry low to limit further softening and shrinkage. | Machine wash cold and hang or tumble dry low; iron poplin styles for a sharper collar and placket. |
Lucky Brand's $69.50 western shirt is a vintage-leaning casual piece in washed cotton; Abercrombie's Signature Poplin ($70) is a tidier smart-casual shirt in crisp poplin and oxford with cleaner construction. Fifty cents apart, but they dress for different rooms.
Lived-in washed cottons, vintage western styling, tapered drape, longer tails, regularly discounted
Crisper poplin finish, tidy construction, consistent collars, slim/classic/relaxed cuts, smart-casual ready
Which should you buy?
At a fifty-cent difference, ignore the price and pick by occasion. Buy the Lucky Brand for casual, western-inspired outfits worn open over a tee. Buy the Abercrombie if you want something that reads smart-casual for date-night or dressed-up weekends, with a crisper finish and cleaner collars. Both drop often in promotions, so the real choice is vintage-soft versus crisp-and-tidy.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.