H&M vs Old Navy: which jean wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the H&M Loose Fit Jeans (men's) at $35, the Old Navy Wow Loose Wide-Leg Jeans (women's) at $35. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| H&M | Old Navy | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35 | $35 |
| Material | Cotton blend, ~11oz, usually with 1–2% elastane; fabric weight varies between production runs. | Mid-weight cotton blend (~10–11oz) with a small percentage of elastane; lighter washes are noticeably thinner. |
| Fit | Loose through thigh and calf, mid-rise. Sizing is inconsistent drop-to-drop — try in store if you can. Generous through the seat. | Wide leg, mid-rise. True to size at the waist for most; the inseam runs long, so shorter wearers frequently hem. Sizing down one is common if you want a slightly cleaner waist. |
| Quality | Fast-fashion build. Knees and seat thin first; light hardware; the colour fades quickly regardless of care. | Budget construction. The colour fades fast and the lighter washes thin at the inner thigh first; stitching itself holds up reasonably for the price. |
| Best for | Trend-driven outfits and throwaway rotation pairs; testing a baggy shape before buying something better made. | Trend-led casual outfits, warm-weather rotation, and anyone wanting to try the wide-leg look without a real commitment. |
| Care | Cold wash inside-out and line dry — the dryer visibly degrades the thin fabric within a couple of months. | Wash cold inside-out and hang dry — owners report the dryer accelerates the fade and shrinks the already-long inseam unpredictably. |
H&M's Loose Fit and Old Navy's Wow Wide-Leg are both $35 of budget trend denim at roughly the same ~10–11oz weight — but the H&M is a men's baggy cut and the Old Navy a women's wide-leg, so for most shoppers the wardrobe decides before the wallet does. With no price gap at all, the real comparison is sizing predictability and how fast each wears out.
- The case for H&M
- Men's loose cut with a generous seat and room through thigh and calf; slightly heavier ~11oz fabric; honest $35 pricing for a disposable trend pair.
- The case for Old Navy
- True-to-size waist and far more predictable ordering; stitching holds up reasonably for the price; a wide-leg shape that mimics pairs costing five to six times more; a long inseam that hems cleanly for shorter wearers.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Pick by cut first: the H&M is the men's baggy option here, the Old Navy the women's wide-leg. On the sizing question these searches keep asking, Old Navy is the safer online order — true to size at the waist, with a long inseam you simply hem — while H&M's sizing drifts drop-to-drop and really wants an in-store try. There's no markup to weigh at identical prices; both fade fast and thin early, so buy whichever silhouette you actually want and treat it as a one-season purchase.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.