Lacoste vs Buck Mason: which sweater wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Lacoste Crew Neck Cotton Sweater (men's) at $125, the Buck Mason Cotton Boatbuilder Sweater at $128, just $3 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Lacoste | Buck Mason | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $125 | $128 |
| Material | 100% organic cotton in a fine-gauge jersey knit with ribbed waist and cuffs; a lighter knit rather than a chunky or wool piece. | Substantial cotton (wool blends available), heavier gauge. |
| Fit | Regular fit. Lacoste's European sizing generally runs about a size small by US standards, so sizing up is the safer call if between sizes; independent coverage of this specific sweater's fit is limited. | Tailored-classic fit, true to size; substantial. |
| Quality | The brand leans on its long knitwear history, and on-site reviewers rate the sweater well, though independent reviews are sparse. Fine cotton jersey knits of this type can stretch at the cuffs with wear and depend on flat drying to hold their shape. | Premium — heavy-gauge knit, durable construction, holds shape across years. |
| Best for | Shoppers who want a light, plain cotton crew with the crocodile for smart-casual wear rather than warmth. | Heritage-Americana outfits, durable cold-weather layering, and a characterful cotton knit. |
| Care | Machine wash cold on a gentle setting and dry flat; the brand says no tumble drying, and cotton knits stretch if hung to dry wet. | Machine wash gentle cold (cotton) or wool cycle (blends) and lay flat to dry. |
At a $3 price difference, this is effectively a same-price decision between two very different garments: the Lacoste is a light cotton jersey knit priced largely on its crocodile logo, while the Buck Mason is a heavier-gauge cotton built for durability and cold-weather use. The gap in material substance is far wider than the gap in price, which makes the choice unusually straightforward.
- The case for Lacoste
- The Lacoste wins for shoppers who specifically want a lightweight, smooth-faced cotton layer for smart-casual settings where the logo carries social currency — it is not competing on construction.
- The case for Buck Mason
- The Buck Mason wins on material substance: the heavier gauge holds its shape across years where fine cotton jersey is prone to cuff stretch and deformation, and it functions as genuine cold-weather layering rather than a transitional piece.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Lacoste if the crocodile is the point and the use case is a light, polished layer for mild temperatures — but recognize that $125 is inflated for the actual knit, and waiting for one of Lacoste's frequent 30–50% off sales is the rational move. Step up to the Buck Mason if the goal is a durable, characterful cotton sweater that earns its price through construction rather than branding — at $128, reviewers consistently treat it as a considered long-term buy, not a logo purchase, and the $3 premium over the Lacoste is entirely justified by the heavier gauge and documented shape retention.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.