Good American vs Re/Done: which top wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the Good American Sculpting Modern Tank Bodysuit at $79, the Re/Done Ribbed Tank at $95, just $16 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Good American | Re/Done | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $79 | $95 |
| Material | Good American lists the fabric as 78% Nylon, 22% Elastane — a double-knit compression stretch rather than a thin jersey. | The brand lists it as 100% cotton rib, knitted and sewn in the USA. |
| Fit | Square neckline, curve-hugging compression, thong back. The sculpting fabric runs small; retailer guidance is to order one size up, especially for all-day wear. | Scoop neck with slim straps and an intentionally tight, regular-length cut. It runs small, and both the brand and its retailers advise sizing up. |
| Quality | The double-knit fabric is substantial and smooths reliably, but a 3.3-star average across 60 reviews at a major department-store retailer points to mixed owner experiences, mostly around sizing and how tight the compression feels. | Construction is simple — a single-fabric cotton rib knitted and sewn in the USA. Owner reports describe fabric that stays comfortable and keeps its snug hold with wear, with slight sheerness as the main trade-off. |
| Best for | Best for anyone who wants a smoothing, stay-put layer under jeans or a blazer and will trade hand-washing for real compression. | Right for someone who wants one snug, US-made rib tank for layering and everyday wear and is willing to pay premium-tier money for it. |
| Care | Good American says hand wash cold or dry clean — more upkeep than a typical knit bodysuit, so factor that into everyday rotation. | Retailer guidance is to wash cold; air-drying is the safer route to keep the tight rib fit predictable. |
These are two different garments solving two different problems: the Good American is a compression bodysuit engineered to smooth and sculpt under clothing, while the Re/Done is a simple cotton rib tank built for everyday layering and wear-in comfort. The $16 gap is almost beside the point — the construction, function, and care requirements diverge enough that most buyers will self-select before price becomes the deciding factor. Where price genuinely matters is that the Re/Done charges upper-premium rates for a structurally straightforward single-fabric knit, while the Good American delivers a technically denser, more engineered garment for less money.
- The case for Good American
- The Good American's double-knit 78% nylon/22% elastane compression construction does measurable smoothing work that a simple rib knit cannot replicate, making it the more functional garment for its stated purpose.
- The case for Re/Done
- The Re/Done's 100% cotton rib, knitted and sewn in the USA, offers breathable all-day comfort and a wear-in quality that owners describe as consistent over time, with no hand-wash requirement.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Good American if the goal is a smoothing underlayer for structured outfits — it delivers real compression for less money, and waiting for a discount code closes the price gap further; the hand-wash requirement is the only meaningful cost. Buy the Re/Done if the need is a reliable, US-made everyday rib tank for casual layering, and natural fiber comfort outweighs function — but go in knowing the $95 price reflects brand positioning at least as much as construction merit, since the garment itself is a simple single-fabric knit. The $16 premium for the Re/Done is not justified by what the fabric or construction actually delivers over the Good American; it is justified only if US-made cotton is a non-negotiable personal criterion.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.