Gildan vs Hanes: which t-shirt to buy, and when
Both land in the budget tier: the Gildan Softstyle / Ultra Cotton Tee at $8, the Hanes Beefy-T Heavyweight Tee at $12, $4 apart. Here is how they stack up, head to head.
| Gildan | Hanes | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $8 | $12 |
| Material | Ringspun cotton; Softstyle ~4.5oz, Ultra Cotton ~6oz. Some colours are cotton/poly blends. | 100% cotton, ~6oz heavyweight ringspun. |
| Fit | Softstyle runs fitted and slightly short; Ultra Cotton runs boxy and true. Both shrink about a size if machine-dried hot. | Boxy and roomy; runs large. Buy your size and expect it to shrink toward true after the first hot wash. |
| Quality | Functional blank quality. Seams hold but the collar loses shape over time and lighter colours thin first. | Sturdy for the price — thick cotton holds opacity and shape; the collar is the first thing to ripple over years. |
| Best for | Layering, yard work, printing on, and anyone who wants a tee they can ruin without a second thought. | Everyday wear, layering, and anyone who wants a thick, opaque budget tee with room to move. |
| Care | Wash cold and hang dry to limit the noticeable shrink — these are notorious for tightening up in a hot dryer. | Wash cold and tumble low; the cotton shrinks a half-to-full size if dried hot from new. |
Gildan's Softstyle/Ultra Cotton is an $8 functional blank — ringspun cotton at ~4.5–6oz that shrinks about a size in a hot dryer and loses its collar over time. The Hanes Beefy-T is $12 of genuine 6oz heavyweight cotton that holds opacity and shape. The $4 gap is small money for a real durability step.
- The case for Gildan
- $4 cheaper and effectively disposable, fine for layering, yard work, and printing on, with a fitted Softstyle option the boxy Beefy-T doesn't offer.
- The case for Hanes
- Genuine 6oz heavyweight cotton that stays opaque and holds its shape for years, sturdier overall, undercuts tees costing three times more.
VerdictThe pick
Buy the Gildan at $8 only when disposability is the point — print blanks, yard work, layers you'll ruin — because the collar loses shape and lighter colours thin first, and both cuts shrink about a size if hot-dried. For a tee you'll actually wear, step up to the Beefy-T at $12: the thick 6oz cotton keeps its opacity and shape, and its only long-term weakness is collar ripple after years, not months. The receipts ask which brand wins on t-shirts, and here it's Hanes without much argument — $4 buys a tee that lasts instead of one you replace. Size note either way: the Beefy-T runs large and shrinks toward true; the Gildan just shrinks.
This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.