Gildan vs Hanes: which hoodie wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the Gildan Heavy Blend Hooded Sweatshirt at $16, the Hanes EcoSmart Pullover Hoodie at $20, just $4 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Gildan | Hanes | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $16 | $20 |
| Material | 50/50 cotton/polyester fleece, ~8oz. | Cotton/polyester EcoSmart fleece, ~9oz, with recycled content. |
| Fit | Boxy and roomy, runs large; shrinks toward true after a hot wash. | Boxy everyday fit, true to size; reads relaxed. |
| Quality | Functional blank quality — warm and opaque, but the fleece pills and the cuffs lose stretch over time. | Budget — warm and opaque, but the fleece pills and colour fades with regular washing. |
| Best for | Layering, around-the-house warmth, printing on, and a hoodie you won't baby. | Everyday warmth, layering, printing on, and a no-worry budget hoodie. |
| Care | Wash cold and tumble low to limit the shrink and pilling the blend is prone to. | Cold wash and tumble low to slow the pilling and keep the colour. |
Two budget blanks doing the same job: Gildan's Heavy Blend is ~8oz 50/50 fleece at $16, Hanes's EcoSmart is ~9oz cotton/poly fleece with recycled content at $20. Both are warm, opaque, boxy, and prone to pilling — the $4 gap buys an ounce of fleece and a true-to-size fit.
- The case for Gildan
- $4 cheaper for genuinely warm, opaque fleece — as close to free as a hoodie gets, ideal for printing on and wearing without a second thought.
- The case for Hanes
- Slightly heavier ~9oz fleece, recycled content, and a true-to-size boxy fit versus the Gildan's runs-large-then-shrinks sizing.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
These are peers, and either is a fine answer at this money. Buy the Gildan at $16 if price is the only variable — it's warm, opaque, and exactly as disposable as $16 implies, though the cuffs lose stretch and it runs large until a hot wash shrinks it toward true. Take the Hanes at $20 if you want the marginally heavier fleece and a fit that's right out of the bag, accepting that its colour fades with regular washing. Both pill, both are boxy, and neither will outlive hard use — so buy on price and sizing convenience, not on any quality gap, because there isn't one.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.