& Other Stories vs Everlane: is the pricier top worth it?
The Everlane The Tie Back Cami in Washable Silk runs $128; the & Other Stories Mulberry Silk Blouse is $169 — about 1.3× the price ($41 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Everlane | & Other Stories | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $128 | $169 |
| Material | Machine-washable silk — Everlane calls it Clean Silk — with a sueded, matte texture that reviewers describe as noticeably thicker than conventional silk. | The brand's own listing says the current version is "crafted from 100% mulberry silk" with a lightweight, semi-sheer finish; one owner notes the silk is on the thinner side rather than a heavyweight weave. |
| Fit | The brand describes a loose, flowy fit with an adjustable tie back. A petite reviewer found Everlane's silk tops draped without chest gapping and called the newer washable-silk pieces more petite-friendly; owner reports on cami sizing are split, so check the size chart against a cami you own. | Runs long and straight in the body — the brand cuts for taller frames and offers no petite range, and one owner wished the sleeves were an inch shorter. US sizes run 0-14, and forum posters advise going a size up if busty. |
| Quality | Independent reviewers rate Everlane's silk as feeling comparable to pricier silk and repeat-purchase pieces from the washable line. The sanded fabric is opaque and holds up to gentle machine washing, though it trades away the sheen of traditional silk. | A long-term owner who wore hers at least monthly for about a year says she "cannot fault the quality," even after repeated machine washing against label advice. The trade-off is a thinner, semi-sheer silk, not a heavyweight one. |
| Best for | Someone who wants a silk cami for layering under blazers or wearing out without dry-cleaning upkeep, ideally bought on one of Everlane's frequent markdowns. | Right for someone who wants a real-silk blouse with feminine detailing for office-to-evening wear at high-street pricing, and who doesn't mind ironing. |
| Care | Machine wash cold on a gentle cycle with like colors, then line dry or lay flat; steam or use a warm iron if needed. | The label calls for dry cleaning, though one long-term owner machine-washes hers with her whites without damage — expect heavy creasing that needs an actual iron rather than a steamer. |
These two are not equivalent products: Everlane offers a thicker, opaque, matte-finish washable silk with explicit machine-wash approval, while & Other Stories offers thinner, semi-sheer true mulberry silk with a conventional blouse construction that the label says requires dry cleaning. The $41 list-price gap narrows or reverses on sale — both brands discount heavily — but the underlying materials and use cases diverge more than the price difference implies.
- The case for Everlane
- Everlane's sanded, heavier-weight silk is opaque, officially machine-washable, and consistently praised as more forgiving to wear and care for, making it the more practical daily layering piece.
- The case for & Other Stories
- & Other Stories delivers certified mulberry silk — thinner and semi-sheer, but genuinely the real thing — with a polished blouse silhouette suited to office-to-evening wear, at a price point well below dedicated silk labels.
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
Buy the Everlane if the priority is a no-fuss silk-feel cami for layering under blazers or wearing casually without dry-cleaning anxiety — and buy it on markdown, where it prices honestly for what it is. Step up to the & Other Stories if the goal is a stand-alone silk blouse with dressy presence and true mulberry-silk credentials matter, accepting that it is thin, needs ironing rather than steaming, and technically requires dry cleaning regardless of what one owner gets away with. The $41 gap is not justified at full list — both brands inflate opening prices and discount routinely — but at their respective sale prices the & Other Stories is buying real mulberry silk and a more structured blouse cut, which is a meaningful difference for anyone who needs the garment to work as a blouse rather than a cami.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.