Drake's vs John Elliott: which button-up wins?
Both land in the luxury tier — the Drake's Cotton Oxford Button-Down at $245, the John Elliott John Elliott Cloak Button-Up Shirt at $248, just $3 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Drake's | John Elliott | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $245 | $248 |
| Material | Substantial cotton oxford or poplin, unlined collar. | Soft cotton, breathable linen, and textured or slubbed wovens chosen for an easy, premium drape and hand. |
| Fit | Elegant relaxed fit, true to size; intentionally easy, not slim. | Relaxed modern fit with a clean shoulder and fluid body; cut for an easy, contemporary line rather than a sharp one. |
| Quality | Luxury — substantial cloth, excellent unlined collar roll, refined construction. | Clean seams, considered buttons, and tidy collars give a refined, minimalist finish. Construction matches the premium tier. |
| Best for | A buy-once oxford, Anglo-Italian smart-casual, and collar-roll connoisseurs. | Elevated-casual, minimalist wardrobes, worn open over a tee or with soft trousers for a relaxed LA look. |
| Care | Cold wash and hang or press; the oxford softens and the collar roll improves with wear. | Machine wash cold or follow garment labels; wear linen with a natural crease and steam cotton to refresh. |
Drake's gives you a substantial cotton oxford with a famous unlined rolling collar built to last for years, while John Elliott's Cloak Shirt is a softer, drapier LA-minimalist piece in slubbed cottons and linen. The $3 gap is rounding error here; the real choice is collar-roll and Anglo-Italian structure versus fluid drape and a relaxed contemporary line.
Substantial oxford cloth, unlined rolling collar, buy-once durability, refined Anglo-Italian cut
Soft drapey hand-feel, clean shoulder, minimalist styling, easy modern line
Which should you buy?
At $245 and $248 this is a wash on money, so buy on character. Get the Drake's if you want a structured oxford with that prized collar roll that holds up for years and reads smart-casual. Pay the trivial $3 more for the John Elliott only if you want the softer, looser LA drape worn open over a tee. Neither is a compromise on construction; pick the one whose silhouette you actually wear.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.