Diesel vs AllSaints: which button-up to buy, and when
Both land in the premium tier: the Diesel Denim Western Shirt at $128, the AllSaints Slim Cotton Shirt at $129, $1 apart. Here is how they stack up, head to head.
| Diesel | AllSaints | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $128 | $129 |
| Material | Washed denim and chambray, cotton twill, and printed cottons, sometimes with a touch of stretch for a closer cut. | Cotton poplin and twill, textured and slubbed cottons, and occasional linen blends chosen for a clean, contemporary drape. |
| Fit | Modern slim-to-regular fit with a contemporary cut; western and denim styles taper through the body. | Slim, body-conscious fit with a sharp shoulder and tapered body; cut close, so those wanting room should size up. |
| Quality | Solid seams and sturdy buttons or snaps for the price, with the washed treatments reading lived-in by design. Built for casual wear. | Clean seams and considered buttons give a tidy finish, with the slim cut driving much of the look. Solid construction for the price point. |
| Best for | Casual, denim-forward and trend-aware looks, worn open over a tee or with jeans. | Sharp contemporary and evening looks, worn tucked or open for a slim, city-leaning silhouette. |
| Care | Wash cold inside out to preserve washes and prints; tumble dry low to limit further fading and shrinkage. | Machine wash cold; iron poplin for crispness and handle textured and printed styles gently. |
The Diesel Denim Western ($128) leans denim-forward: washed denim and chambray, sometimes with a touch of stretch, in a modern slim-to-regular cut with lived-in washes. The AllSaints Slim Cotton ($129) is a sharper, city-leaning poplin and twill shirt with a body-conscious slim fit built for contemporary and evening looks. The $1 difference is noise, so the call is denim casual versus tailored slim cotton.
- The case for Diesel
- washed denim and chambray, lived-in treatments, slim-to-regular cut, western snap detailing, casual denim-forward look
- The case for AllSaints
- slim body-conscious fit, sharp shoulder line, contemporary city styling, tucked or evening looks, frequent sales
VerdictThe pick
A $1 gap means price is irrelevant here. Buy the Diesel if you want a casual, denim-forward shirt with washed treatments to wear open over a tee. Buy the AllSaints if you want a sharper, slim cotton shirt for tucked-in or evening city looks, and note its frequent sales can sweeten the deal further. Size up on the AllSaints if you want any room, since it's cut close.
This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.