Columbia vs Eddie Bauer: which jacket wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Columbia Watertight II Jacket at $100, the Eddie Bauer CirrusLite Down Jacket at $129, just $29 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Columbia | Eddie Bauer | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $100 | $129 |
| Material | A 2-layer, 100% nylon shell with Columbia's Omni-Tech waterproof-breathable coating and a mesh liner, independently tested at a 10,000 mm waterproof rating. | A 100% nylon shell with StormRepel DWR over 650-fill Responsible Down Standard down, with the current version using recycled shell and lining fabric. |
| Fit | A standard cut that many owners find baggy, which makes layering underneath easy. Size down if you want a trimmer fit; testers generally liked the relaxed fit for casual wear. | Classic, slightly roomy cut with space to layer a fleece underneath, and a high neckline that owners say helps hold in warmth. Most report true-to-size fit; Eddie Bauer's own size guide recommends sizing up if between sizes. |
| Quality | Reviewers describe the 2-layer shell as surprisingly durable for the price and expect it to last multiple seasons. Known weak points are the interior mesh liner, which can snag, and seams that can eventually soak through in prolonged heavy rain. | Testers report clean stitching and consistent baffling for the price, and long-term reviews are largely positive. The trade-off is a thin, light shell that gear reviewers found less durable than heavier jackets, so it works better as a layer than as a bushwhacking outer. |
| Best for | Commuters, travelers, and casual hikers who want a packable shell for light-to-moderate rain rather than sustained downpours or high-output activity. | Three-season layering, travel, and everyday cold-weather wear for buyers who want genuine down warmth at the lowest credible price, not a standalone deep-winter coat. |
| Care | Machine wash cold on gentle without fabric softener, then tumble dry low, which helps revive the water-repellent finish. | Machine wash cold on a delicate cycle with mild detergent, then tumble dry low with a clean tennis ball to restore loft — no fabric softener and no dry cleaning. |
These two jackets solve different cold-weather problems: the Columbia Watertight II is a waterproof rain shell with no insulation, while the Eddie Bauer CirrusLite is an insulated down layer with only a light DWR finish rather than a true waterproof membrane. The $29 list-price gap is almost beside the point because shoppers are not choosing between a cheaper and a pricier version of the same thing — they are choosing between two functionally distinct garments, and Eddie Bauer's near-constant sales routinely bring the CirrusLite to roughly $65, making the real-world gap even smaller or reversed.
- The case for Columbia
- The Columbia is the only one of the two that keeps rain out in sustained precipitation, backed by a tested 10,000 mm waterproof rating and a sealed-shell construction designed specifically to shed water rather than merely repel light moisture.
- The case for Eddie Bauer
- The Eddie Bauer delivers genuine 650-fill down warmth at a price where real down insulation is otherwise rare, making it the more useful garment on cold, dry days where staying warm matters more than staying dry.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Columbia if the primary need is staying dry in rain — commuters, travelers in wet climates, and anyone caught in more than a light drizzle will find the waterproof shell does a job the CirrusLite simply cannot. Step up to the Eddie Bauer if the need is warmth on dry or lightly damp cold days, where it functions well as a midlayer or standalone insulator; at its frequent sale price it represents fair value for real down, whereas paying $129 list is unnecessary given how reliably discounts appear. The $29 gap at list is not the real question — the two jackets are not interchangeable, and a buyer who needs both waterproofing and warmth should treat these as separate tools rather than alternatives.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.