Buck Mason vs Taylor Stitch: which zip-up wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the Buck Mason Heavyweight Zip Hoodie at $138, the Taylor Stitch Après Zip Hoodie at $138. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Buck Mason | Taylor Stitch | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $138 | $138 |
| Material | Dense heavyweight cotton loopback fleece that holds its shape and develops a broken-in feel with wear. | Heavyweight 14-oz. 100% organic cotton French terry with a smooth face, cozy interior and a dense hand that breaks in over time. |
| Fit | Trim-classic cut that's clean through the body without being tight; true to size with a slightly structured shoulder. | Classic, slightly relaxed cut with room to layer; generally true to size. |
| Quality | Sturdy metal-tooth zipper, thick ribbing and tidy flatlock-style seams; built to last and resist sagging. | Two-way YKK zipper, heavyweight ribbing at every opening and a lined three-piece hood; built to take wear and develop character. |
| Best for | Buyers wanting a heavyweight, logo-free zip hoodie with a structured cut and durable construction. | Buyers wanting a durable, heavyweight organic-cotton zip hoodie with a rugged everyday character. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low or hang dry; the heavy cotton may shrink slightly on first wash. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; indigo colorways can transfer dye onto light fabrics at first. |
Two heavyweight cotton zip hoodies at the same $138 from two brands shoppers constantly cross-shop. Both use dense cotton fabric that breaks in with wear, a sturdy zipper, and thick ribbing, so the real differences are cut and fiber sourcing, not build quality.
- The case for Buck Mason
- The Buck Mason has a trim-classic cut, a slightly structured shoulder, and dense loopback fleece that resists sagging — the sharper-looking option worn over a tee.
- The case for Taylor Stitch
- The Après Zip counters with 14-oz organic cotton French terry, a slightly relaxed cut with room to layer over heavier pieces, and a two-way YKK zipper with thick ribbing at every opening.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Buck Mason if you want the cleaner, more structured silhouette worn trim over a tee — you give up nothing in construction. Pick the Après Zip if you layer over button-ups or the organic-cotton sourcing matters to you; its relaxed cut is built for exactly that. At the same price the gap is pure fit philosophy — the only wrong move is choosing by brand name instead of by how you'll wear it.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.