Buck Mason vs Aritzia: which sweater wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Buck Mason Cotton Boatbuilder Sweater at $128, the Aritzia Wool-Cashmere Knit Sweater at $128. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Buck Mason | Aritzia | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $128 | $128 |
| Material | Substantial cotton (wool blends available), heavier gauge. | Merino, wool-cashmere or plush synthetic blend depending on style, mid gauge. |
| Fit | Tailored-classic fit, true to size; substantial. | Trend-led cut, often oversized or cropped; check the style. |
| Quality | Premium — heavy-gauge knit, durable construction, holds shape across years. | Mid-tier — soft, on-trend; wool-cashmere styles are best, plush blends pill. |
| Best for | Heritage-Americana outfits, durable cold-weather layering, and a characterful cotton knit. | On-trend soft knitwear, oversized and cropped cuts, and seasonal looks. |
| Care | Machine wash gentle cold (cotton) or wool cycle (blends) and lay flat to dry. | Hand-wash or gentle wool cycle and lay flat; de-pill plush styles early. |
Buck Mason's Boatbuilder is a heavy, made-to-last cotton knit with a tailored-classic shape; Aritzia's wool-cashmere is a softer, trend-led cut that runs oversized or cropped. Both land at $128, so this is purely about what you want from a sweater. Durable structure and heritage character versus on-trend softness and a fashion silhouette.
Heavy durable cotton knit, holds shape for years, tailored-classic fit, rugged heritage character, made to last
Softer wool-cashmere hand, on-trend oversized cuts, cropped seasonal styles, mid-gauge warmth, fashion-forward silhouette
Which should you buy?
Same $128 price, so buy on character. Get the Buck Mason if you want a substantial cotton sweater that keeps its shape for years and reads rugged-refined. Get the Aritzia if you want soft wool-cashmere warmth and a trend-led oversized or cropped cut, but stick to its merino or wool-cashmere styles and skip the plush polyester blends, which pill. The Aritzia is the seasonal fashion piece; the Buck Mason is the long-haul staple.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.