Brooks Brothers vs Polo Ralph Lauren: which button-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down (OCBD) at $98, the Polo Ralph Lauren Classic Fit Oxford Shirt at $98. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Brooks Brothers | Polo Ralph Lauren | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98 | $98 |
| Material | Substantial cotton oxford cloth, mid-heavy weight. | Soft cotton oxford, mid-weight. |
| Fit | Traditional full fit (slimmer cuts available), true to size; size down if you want trim. | Multiple fits (classic/slim/custom), true to size; classic runs full. |
| Quality | Heritage benchmark — substantial oxford, the signature soft collar roll, durable construction. | Solid — soft oxford, relaxed collar roll, durable; mid-weight rather than the heaviest cloth. |
| Best for | The classic OCBD look, smart-casual and office wear, and collar-roll enthusiasts. | The Ivy-style OCBD look, smart-casual wear, and anyone who wants the widest colour range. |
| Care | Cold wash and hang or press; the oxford softens and the collar develops its roll with wear. | Cold wash and hang or press; the soft oxford develops a relaxed collar roll with wear. |
Both are $98 Ivy-style oxford button-downs: Brooks Brothers brings substantial mid-heavy cloth and the benchmark collar roll, while Polo Ralph Lauren runs a softer mid-weight oxford with the widest color range and multiple fits. The choice is cloth weight and collar character versus color selection and fit options.
Heavier substantial oxford, signature collar roll, category benchmark, durable mid-heavy cloth
Widest colour range, softer mid-weight oxford, classic/slim/custom fits, relaxed collar roll, reviewers say it lasts
Which should you buy?
Same money, so weigh cloth against choice. Get the Brooks Brothers for the more substantial oxford and the stronger collar roll, the closest thing to the original OCBD. Get the Polo if you want a softer hand, a specific color, or a fit other than full. Both are best bought on each brand's frequent promotions, so let availability and color break the tie.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.