& Other Stories vs J.Crew: which zip-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the & Other Stories & Other Stories Cotton Zip Hoodie at $89, the J.Crew J.Crew Cotton Full-Zip Hoodie at $90, just $1 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| & Other Stories | J.Crew | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $89 | $90 |
| Material | Soft cotton fleece, mid-weight with a smooth brushed interior and clean surface. | Heavyweight cotton fleece with a brushed loopback interior; substantial and warm without technical fibers. |
| Fit | Clean contemporary cut, often slightly relaxed or cropped; check the specific style for fit. | Classic straight cut, neither slim nor baggy; true to size with room for a tee underneath. |
| Quality | Tidy zipper, neat seams and clean trims; finishing supports the considered minimal aesthetic. | YKK-style zipper, ribbed trims and clean topstitching; finishing is dependable and the fabric holds up to repeated washing. |
| Best for | Design-minded shoppers wanting a clean, minimal cotton zip hoodie with a European sensibility. | Prep-leaning casual wardrobes wanting a clean cotton zip hoodie for layering over collared shirts and tees. |
| Care | Machine wash cold gentle and lay flat or tumble dry low to keep the soft cotton in shape. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; expect minor first-wash shrinkage typical of cotton fleece. |
Both are cotton zip hoodies around $89, but J.Crew's is a heavyweight loopback fleece built for layering, while & Other Stories runs mid-weight with a brushed interior and a more minimal cut. The 50-cent gap means this comes down to weight and styling, not money.
smoother minimal styling, lighter mid-weight feel, cropped/relaxed options, European sensibility
heavyweight warmer fleece, classic true-to-size cut, YKK-style zipper, frequent J.Crew markdowns
Which should you buy?
Spend on neither for the price's sake since they're within fifty cents. Buy the J.Crew for a substantial, warm hoodie that layers over tees and collared shirts and routinely drops below sticker in promotions. Choose & Other Stories if you want a lighter, cleaner look and a slightly more fashion-forward cut. Cold-weather layerers should take the heavyweight J.Crew; anyone after a trimmer minimal piece picks the other.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.