& Other Stories vs Calvin Klein: which button-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the & Other Stories & Other Stories Relaxed Cotton Shirt at $89, the Calvin Klein Steel Solid Slim Fit Button-Down Shirt (men's) at $89. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| & Other Stories | Calvin Klein | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $89 | $89 |
| Material | Cotton poplin, breathable linen, and printed wovens, with some fluid viscose or TENCEL blends for drape. | Cotton with stretch and a wrinkle-free finish; the line's dress versions add moisture-wicking claims. The fabric runs lightweight, and some reviewers note white versions are somewhat see-through over an undershirt. |
| Fit | Relaxed, feminine cuts with a clean shoulder and easy body; many styles are meant to drape loosely or tuck softly. | Slim and fitted through the chest, sleeves and waist, sized by neck and sleeve length. Reviewers describe it as genuinely slim rather than nominally so; classic-fit versions exist in the wider line for broader builds. |
| Quality | Tidy seams and considered buttons give a polished finish, though the lighter fabrics favor drape over durability. Solid for the price. | Reviewers describe clean stitching and a consistent cut, and several rate it above shirts costing much more. The main knocks are the lightweight, occasionally sheer fabric and the non-iron claim falling short for a minority of owners. |
| Best for | Design-forward women's casual and smart-casual looks, worn open over a tank or tucked into trousers. | Commuters and office workers who want a genuinely slim, low-maintenance shirt at a mall price and would rather skip the ironing board. |
| Care | Machine wash cold or follow garment labels; iron poplin and wear linen with a natural crease. | Machine wash and tumble dry low — the shirt is designed to be worn straight from the dryer. High heat and ironing shorten the life of the wrinkle-free finish and the stretch fibers. |
At identical $89 list prices, these shirts occupy entirely different categories: one is a women's design-forward casual piece in natural and semi-natural fabrics, the other a men's slim office shirt built around stretch-cotton and a wrinkle-free finish. The practical gap is that the Calvin Klein's street price regularly drops to $30–40 through routine promotions, making its true cost substantially lower than the & Other Stories price, which discounts less aggressively and holds closer to list.
- The case for & Other Stories
- & Other Stories wins on fabric character and design intention: cotton poplin, linen, and TENCEL blends prioritize drape, texture, and considered styling details over functional shortcuts.
- The case for Calvin Klein
- The Calvin Klein wins on low-maintenance practicality: machine wash, tumble dry, wear straight from the dryer — a genuinely useful feature set for daily office commuting, and one that delivers real cost-per-wear value once the street discount is applied.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Calvin Klein if the buyer is a man who needs a reliably slim, low-maintenance office shirt and is willing to wait for the near-certain 40-percent discount, at which point the wrinkle-free convenience is a reasonable trade for the lightweight, occasionally sheer fabric. Buy the & Other Stories if the buyer is a woman shopping for casual-to-smart-casual styling with natural fabric drape and design detail — the $89 price is closer to honest here, the fabric quality is better suited to the relaxed-wear context, and the styling investment is what the markup actually pays for.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.