American Giant vs John Elliott: which sweatshirt wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the American Giant American Vintage Crew Sweatshirt at $135, the John Elliott Beach Crew 2 at $168, just $33 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| American Giant | John Elliott | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $135 | $168 |
| Material | American Giant makes it from a substantial 16 oz fleece — knit from what the brand states is 100% USA-grown cotton — with a garment wash that gives it a faded, broken-in finish. | 100% cotton custom-knit French terry with rib-knit collar, waist, and cuffs; current production is made in Peru. |
| Fit | It is a gender-neutral piece with a deliberately oversized, relaxed silhouette, so buyers wanting a conventional fit should consider sizing down. Sizing is not uniform across the brand's sweatshirt line — one independent tester found some pieces ran small — so checking the size chart is worth the minute. | Relaxed through the body with a subtle crop, and a revised fit in the arms and body compared with the original Beach Crew. Brand guidance is true to size; buyers who dislike any crop may prefer sizing up. |
| Quality | An independent months-long test of the brand's clothes found no color fading, loose threads, or shrinkage despite near-daily wear, which matches the multi-year service reports that follow its heavyweight fleece. | John Elliott's custom-spec terry has a long-standing community reputation for comfort and durability, and this crew keeps construction simple: rib-knit trim and tonal stitching. Owner reports specific to the Beach Crew 2 are still thin, so long-term durability is not yet well documented. |
| Best for | Right for someone who wants one heavy, US-made crewneck to wear hard for years and prefers a roomy, broken-in look over a trim cut. | Buyers who want a plain, logo-free fleece crew with a current, slightly cropped silhouette and are willing to pay premium-tier money for custom-knit fabric. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; the heavy cotton fleece handles frequent washing well, but high dryer heat risks shrinking it. | Machine wash cold and skip high heat — a cropped cotton French terry crew has little length to spare to shrinkage. |
Both are relaxed, logo-free cotton crewnecks in a similar price band, but they are built on different premises: the American Giant is a 16 oz heavyweight workhorse with documented multi-year durability, made from US-grown cotton and sewn domestically, while the John Elliott is a lighter custom-knit French terry piece whose appeal is a current, slightly cropped silhouette and fabric hand — not proven longevity. The $33 gap is narrow in absolute terms but significant when one product has an established durability record and the other does not.
- The case for American Giant
- The American Giant wins on verified long-term durability — independent months-long near-daily wear produced no fading, shrinkage, or loose threads — and its 16 oz fabric weight and US-made supply chain give the price genuine structural justification.
- The case for John Elliott
- The John Elliott wins on silhouette currency — the subtle crop and revised arm fit read as a more considered, contemporary cut for buyers to whom a slightly modern proportion matters more than maximum fabric heft.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the American Giant if the goal is a single heavy crewneck to wear hard for several years: the durability data is real, the fabric weight is documented, and $135 is defensible for what the garment physically is. Step up to the John Elliott only if the cropped, contemporary fit is specifically what is wanted and the buyer accepts that at $168 — the ceiling of the premium tier — long-term durability remains undocumented and part of the premium is label positioning rather than proven construction. The $33 gap is not justified by what is currently known: it buys a trendier silhouette and a brand name, not demonstrably better materials or a longer service life.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.