AllSaints vs Nudie Jeans: which button-up wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the AllSaints AllSaints Slim Cotton Shirt at $129, the Nudie Jeans Nudie Jeans Organic Cotton Shirt at $130, just $1 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| AllSaints | Nudie Jeans | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $129 | $130 |
| Material | Cotton poplin and twill, textured and slubbed cottons, and occasional linen blends chosen for a clean, contemporary drape. | Organic cotton chambray, twill, and corduroy, plus washed organic cottons chosen for durability and a clean, lived-in hand. |
| Fit | Slim, body-conscious fit with a sharp shoulder and tapered body; cut close, so those wanting room should size up. | Trim-to-regular fit with a clean shoulder and easy body; cut to layer over a tee without excess bulk. |
| Quality | Clean seams and considered buttons give a tidy finish, with the slim cut driving much of the look. Solid construction for the price point. | Strong seams, sturdy buttons, and durable organic cottons reflect a workwear-minded, sustainable build. Construction is solid and consistent. |
| Best for | Sharp contemporary and evening looks, worn tucked or open for a slim, city-leaning silhouette. | Sustainable, denim-adjacent casual wardrobes, worn as a durable layering shirt with jeans and chinos. |
| Care | Machine wash cold; iron poplin for crispness and handle textured and printed styles gently. | Wash cold inside out to preserve color; tumble dry low and expect the organic cottons to soften over time. |
AllSaints sells a sharp, body-conscious city shirt at $129; Nudie Jeans charges $130 for organic cotton chambray and twill with a workwear-minded, sustainable build. The dollar gap is basically nothing, so this is a question of look versus ethics: AllSaints buys you a tapered evening silhouette, Nudie buys you durable organic cloth and ethical production.
sharp slim silhouette, evening-ready styling, frequent sales, distinctive look, $1 cheaper
organic cotton, ethical production, durable workwear build, easy layering cut, denim-friendly
Which should you buy?
At a one-dollar difference, price is irrelevant here. Buy the AllSaints if you want a slim, tapered shirt for sharp evening and city looks, and watch for its frequent sales to push it lower. Buy the Nudie if you care about organic materials and ethical sourcing and want a sturdier shirt to throw over a tee with jeans. They cost the same, so pick the priority, not the price.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.