7 For All Mankind vs Citizens of Humanity: which jean wins?
Both land in the premium tier — the 7 For All Mankind Slimmy Slim Straight at $198, the Citizens of Humanity Charlotte High-Rise Straight (women's) at $248, just $50 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| 7 For All Mankind | Citizens of Humanity | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $198 | $248 |
| Material | Premium stretch and some rigid denim options, typically cotton with elastane for the stretch fits. | 100% cotton, ~12oz non-stretch denim from premium mills. |
| Fit | The Slimmy is a slim-straight that is fitted but not skin-tight, with a regular rise. Reviewers say it runs true to size and is a reliable everyday cut. | High-rise straight at the natural waist. Runs slightly small at the waist — wearers between sizes size up; rigid cotton with no give, so buy your real waist. |
| Quality | Owners report dependable construction and washes; the stretch versions prioritize comfort while the rigid options wear more traditionally. | Premium construction — stitching, hardware and heavy cloth all above the price; holds shape across years. |
| Best for | Shoppers wanting a polished, proven premium slim jean with broad wash choices. | Premium non-stretch high-rise denim, considered styling, and structured jeans built to last. |
| Care | Wash cold inside out and hang dry to preserve color and shape. | Cold wash inside-out and infrequently; air dry. The indigo deepens with infrequent washing. |
The search is brand versus brand, but these two jeans barely overlap: the $198 Slimmy is a regular-rise slim-straight, typically with stretch for comfort, while the $248 Charlotte is a women's high-rise straight in rigid ~12oz 100% cotton from premium mills. Both are premium denim; only one is built around give.
- The case for 7 For All Mankind
- Fifty dollars cheaper, a fitted-but-not-tight slim-straight that runs true to size, broad wash choices including comfort-stretch options, and fit consistency and finishing owners call reliably worth the premium band.
- The case for Citizens of Humanity
- Genuinely heavier goods — ~12oz non-stretch cotton, stitching and hardware rated above the price, indigo that deepens with infrequent washing, and a shape reviewers say holds across years, a gap over mid-tier denim they call real rather than branding.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Choose by the jean, not the label, because they do different jobs: the Slimmy is soft, forgiving premium denim in a proven everyday cut, and if that is what you want it is the buy and saves $50. The Charlotte's extra $50 is visible in the cloth itself — heavy rigid cotton that breaks in, holds its shape and rewards years of wear, for buyers who specifically want structure over stretch. Mind the opposite sizing traps: the Slimmy runs true, while the Charlotte runs small at the waist with zero give, so buy your real waist measurement or size up between sizes. If you cross-shop these as interchangeable, you will be disappointed by one of them.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.