We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Untuckit button-ups →Star Print Tie-Neck Colette Shirt
The verdict
Fit
Tie-neck detailing adds visual interest. Expect a relaxed fit typical of Untuckit's women's line; the neckline is a design feature.
Quality
Non-cotton blend at 58 USD suggests synthetic or mixed-fiber construction. Durability is adequate; synthetic components can pill.
Is the price fair?
Fair value for a casual statement piece at a discounted price.
Best for
Women wanting a casual black shirt with playful star print and a distinctive tie-neck detail.
Care
Non-cotton blends require gentle washing in cool water and low heat drying.
What owners report about Untuckit button-ups
Editorial testers generally find the shirts deliver on their one promise: hemmed to sit just below the waist in several fits, with soft cotton and clean construction one long-form reviewer called a solid, well-made product that resisted wrinkles through a week of travel. Opinion splits on value at roughly $99-$100 a shirt — one reviewer felt a premium model was noticeably thin and unflattering on first wear, while owner quotes elsewhere say the shirts look and feel better than shirts costing far less and last longer. Ratings on the brand's own site are very high, but third-party platforms run much lower, with shrinkage after machine drying and sizing inconsistency between styles the most repeated owner complaints.
- Strengths
- Purpose-built untucked length in multiple fits; soft, well-made cotton fabrics per editorial testers
- Watch out for
- Owner reports of shrinkage after machine drying and inconsistent sizing between styles; ~$100 price is the recurring gripe; one tester found a premium model thin and unflattering
- Sizing
- Multiple fits offered and generally true to size per testers, but owners report sizing varies between styles and shirts can shrink if machine dried
About Untuckit's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: An Honest Review of Untuckit and the No-Tuck Shirts for Men - The Manual · I Have a Confession to Make: I Wore Untuckit and I Liked It - InsideHook · UNTUCKit Review - Must Read This Before Buying · UNTUCKit Review: My Honest Take on the Internet-Famous Untucked Shirts - Greenlit Content
