We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all The Row button-ups →Melchior Shirt
The verdict
Fit
Row cuts close but measured. True to size delivers their standard fit; size up for relaxation.
Quality
Consistent with Row's line: tight, intentional seaming and premium-weight fabrics. Durability is solid for the price tier.
Is the price fair?
At 1,350 USD, you are paying for Row's positioning and design consistency. Quality is present but not exceptional.
Best for
Men building or completing a Row capsule wardrobe.
Care
Treat as a fine piece; gentle handling and lay-flat drying advised.
What owners report about The Row button-ups
Owners and working stylists report the shirts hold up and get worn constantly: one stylist who owns the Petra shirt describes it as a crisper, slimmer-fitting cotton with a trace of stretch, and a multi-piece owner says her longest-lasting garments come from this brand. Sizing reports split by cut — tailored shirting fits true to size while overshirts and oversized shirts run roomy. The recurring criticism in coverage is price rather than construction; a basic button-down retails around $1,250, and independent reporting on how the shirts fail over time is scarce.
- Strengths
- Owners consistently report fabric quality and longevity — pieces stay in rotation for years without complaints about construction.
- Watch out for
- Price is the near-universal objection (about $1,250 for a plain button-down), and there is little independent durability reporting on the shirts specifically, so buyers are leaning on owner praise rather than long-term test data.
- Sizing
- A luxury-resale size guide reports tailored poplin shirts fit true to size while overshirts and oversized cuts run large, so sizing down is sensible on the roomier styles.
About The Row's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: The Best White Button Down Shirts — Uniform by Ali Pew · The Row Size Guide: What Size Am I in The Row? (Tellar) · The Least Quiet Thing The Row Has Ever Done — Amy Odell, Back Row · all roads lead to (the) row — digital tinz
