We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Re/Done tops →Mock Neck Scallop Tank - Black
The verdict
Fit
Mock necks fit snug at the collarbone; scalloped hems sit on the hip. Re/Done's ATS pieces are slim through the torso.
Quality
ATS (Atelier Time Special) is Re/Done's premium cut-and-sew line. Expect thoughtful seaming and fabric that resists pilling.
Is the price fair?
Fair for a curated Re/Done piece with design details. You're paying for the mock-neck and scallop engineering, not brand bloat.
Best for
Anyone wanting a detailed, designer tank that reads polished in a simple outfit.
Care
Hand wash to protect the scalloped edge detail.
What owners report about Re/Done tops
Testers who compare tees across many labels rate Re/Done's vintage-inspired collaboration tees highly: one reviewer who tried more than fifteen white tees called the classic version "the quintessential casual tee," praising its lightweight, soft jersey and a cut she describes as neither too boxy nor too slim, and a separate 23-shirt try-on kept it among five finalists. Reviewers note the white colorways are not fully opaque and the fabric reads casual rather than dressy. Price for the quality is the recurring complaint — Trustpilot reviewers describe products as "outrageously priced for such poor quality," with reports of tees arriving not as pictured and frustrating returns. Sizing reports also conflict by style: the same comparison tester sized up in the women's classic tee, while a forum member found an XS in the reissue line fitting closer to a medium.
- Strengths
- The classic collaboration tee's soft, lightweight jersey and middle-of-the-road vintage cut make it a repeat favorite in multi-brand white-tee comparisons.
- Watch out for
- Recurring complaints are the price relative to quality, white versions that aren't fully opaque, and sizing that varies noticeably from style to style.
- Sizing
- Expect inconsistency across styles — one tester who normally wears XS–S took a small in the women's classic tee because it "runs a bit small," while a forum report found the reissue line's XS fitting closer to a medium.
About Re/Done's tops line as a whole. Sources: White T-Shirt Contest!!! - by Priyanka Aribindi · RE/DONE Reviews | Trustpilot · I Tried On 23 Highly Recommended White T-Shirts. These 5 Are Worth Keeping. · Hanes 60s t-shirt - anything current exist with same fit? | Styleforum