Marmot Women's Onward Insulated Jacket in Thunderhead

Owners report Marmot fits true to size overall, with the rain pants and some bottoms running slightly roomy.

On the core jackets, retailer fit data is one-sided: every Zappos sizing respondent for the PreCip rated it true to size, with owners noting room for a light layer underneath and some deliberately going up a size only to fit bulky mid-layers. Sizing-guide roundups agree that Marmot jackets typically run true to size and track other American outdoor brands. The soft spot is bottoms: CleverHiker's PreCip Eco rain pants review says the fit runs slightly big and suggests sizing down, and owner feedback on shorts and sweatpants echoes a somewhat generous cut. Cuts also skew trimmer on athletic-fit styles, so per-item reviews are worth a glance on slim-labeled pieces.

Sizing advice: Order your usual size in jackets and tops (go up one only if you layer heavily); consider sizing down in the rain pants and other roomy bottoms.

Per owner & reviewer reports: Marmot PreCip Jacket Reviews — Zappos · Do Marmot Jackets Run Small Or Big? — FabricFits · Marmot PreCip Eco Rain Pants Review — CleverHiker · Marmot PreCip Eco Rain Jacket Review — CleverHiker

Long-term owners describe the down jackets as durable and warm for the price: one outdoor-gear tester had been wearing a Montreaux for five winters without losing feathers, and reviewers rated the Fordham's insulation "above average for its price point" with a "heavy, densely woven, hardwearing exterior shell." Rain-shell owners report a different pattern — waterproofing at the collar and elbows on Precip and Membrain jackets can start failing within about four years, well before the shell fabric itself wears out. At least one buyer of a budget down jacket said the arms felt underfilled and the jacket "feels cheap overall" straight out of the box.

Strengths

Reviewers consistently praise the down jackets' warmth-to-price ratio and shell construction, with some testers reporting five-plus winters of solid wear.

Watch out for

The recurring complaint is that waterproofing on the rain shells tends to fail at the collar and elbows after a few years of use, and a few budget down jackets have been called underfilled or cheap-feeling on arrival.

Sizing

One buyer noted going in that "the reviews say they run a little large," though most sizing feedback found was product-specific rather than line-wide.

About Marmot's jackets & outerwear line as a whole. Sources: Marmot Fordham Review | Tested & Rated · Marmot Montreaux Review | Tested & Rated · How my Marmot Precip and Membrain waterproof breathable jackets failed · Marmot Men's Burdell 600 Fill Down Jacket (Various Colors) - $64.79 | Slickdeals